Original Research — May 2026

NYC's Best-Rated
Healthy Restaurants

546 NYC restaurants rated 4.5+ stars across all 5 boroughs and 12+ neighborhoods. Ranked by community rating with review-count tiebreakers. Sourced from our directory of active NYC healthy restaurants.

Best-rated restaurants in NYC
546

Best-rated restaurants in NYC

Rating ≥ 4.5 · All 5 boroughs

Average rating across this set
★ 4.62

Average rating across this set

Qualifying floor: ★4.5

Reach our elite ★4.7+ tier
189

Reach our elite ★4.7+ tier

35% of qualifying restaurants

Hold a Grade A inspection
31%

Hold a Grade A inspection

170 Grade A holders

How this index works

A restaurant qualifies for this index when it meets all three criteria. Within the qualifying set, restaurants are ranked by community rating, with review count as the tiebreaker.

Rating ≥ 4.5 stars

Above the 4.5-star floor — consistently excellent customer experiences across reviews.

Elite tier: 4.7+

189 restaurants pass the elite 4.7-star threshold — a much higher bar.

Currently operational

Open and serving customers — not closed restaurants with stale legacy reviews.

Ratings are sourced from Google Maps community reviews. Grades and operational status are sourced from the NYC DOHMH Open Data portal. The index regenerates whenever our data is refreshed; current figures are as of May 2026.

Best-rated restaurants by borough

Manhattan dominates by sheer count, but every borough surfaces standout restaurants. Average rating across the qualifying set sits remarkably tight across all five boroughs — quality is everywhere, distribution is uneven.

Top-rated healthy restaurants in Manhattan

Ranked by rating, with review count as the tiebreaker.

All Manhattan restaurants →

Top-rated healthy restaurants in Brooklyn

Ranked by rating, with review count as the tiebreaker.

All Brooklyn restaurants →

Top-rated healthy restaurants in Queens

Ranked by rating, with review count as the tiebreaker.

All Queens restaurants →

Top-rated healthy restaurants in Bronx

Ranked by rating, with review count as the tiebreaker.

All Bronx restaurants →

Top-rated healthy restaurants in Staten Island

Ranked by rating, with review count as the tiebreaker.

All Staten Island restaurants →

Neighborhoods with the most best-rated restaurants

Highest concentration of 4.5+ rated restaurants. Minimum 3 restaurants required to qualify for this list.

  1. 1

    Midtown

    Manhattan

    52

    best-rated

  2. 2

    Hell's Kitchen

    Manhattan

    30

    best-rated

  3. 3

    Flatiron District

    Manhattan

    28

    best-rated

  4. 4

    Greenwich Village

    Manhattan

    22

    best-rated

  5. 5

    Financial District

    Manhattan

    20

    best-rated

  6. 6

    Flushing

    Queens

    19

    best-rated

  7. 7

    Midtown East

    Manhattan

    18

    best-rated

  8. 8

    Chelsea

    Manhattan

    16

    best-rated

  9. 9

    Astoria

    Queens

    16

    best-rated

  10. 10

    Lincoln Square

    Manhattan

    16

    best-rated

  11. 11

    Upper West Side

    Manhattan

    14

    best-rated

  12. 12

    Chinatown

    Manhattan

    13

    best-rated

Perfect 5.0 — the rarest tier

3 restaurants in our directory hold a perfect 5.0 rating across every review they have received. A 5.0 over a meaningful number of reviews is almost unheard of — these are exceptional outliers.

NYC restaurants with a perfect 5.0 community rating.
RestaurantReviews
Awesome Hibachi | Hibachi At Home Hibachi Catering

5.0 perfect

2,061
Foods of NY Tours

5.0 perfect

1,897
Funny Hibachi Catering

5.0 perfect

1,714

The elite 4.7+ tier

The top 25 restaurants in the elite tier (rating ≥ 4.7), sorted by rating then by review count. Across NYC, only 189 restaurants pass this bar.

  1. 1

    Awesome Hibachi | Hibachi At Home Hibachi Catering

    Astoria, Queens · Mobile caterer

    52,061 reviews
  2. 2

    Foods of NY Tours

    Greenwich Village, Manhattan · Sightseeing tour agency

    51,897 reviews
  3. 3

    Funny Hibachi Catering

    Sunset Park, Brooklyn · Caterer

    51,714 reviews
  4. 4

    Mitr Thai Restaurant

    Midtown, Manhattan · Thai restaurant

    4.98,795 reviews
  5. 5

    GAN-HOO BBQ

    Flushing, Queens · Barbecue restaurant

    4.95,618 reviewsGrade A
  6. 6

    Osteria La Baia

    Midtown, Manhattan · Italian restaurant

    4.95,013 reviewsGrade B
  7. 7

    SAPPEISAN

    Greenwich Village, Manhattan · Thai restaurant

    4.94,992 reviews
  8. 8

    Valla Table

    Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan · Thai restaurant

    4.94,974 reviewsGrade C
  9. 9

    Glin Thai Bistro

    Fort Greene, Brooklyn · Thai restaurant

    4.94,369 reviewsGrade A
  10. 10

    Kam Rai Thai

    Astoria, Queens · Restaurant

    4.93,533 reviews
  11. 11

    Aragvi

    Midtown East, Manhattan · Georgian restaurant

    4.93,325 reviewsGrade A
  12. 12

    Sozai Japanese Restaurant (Izakaya Ramen)

    Midtown, Manhattan · Japanese restaurant

    4.93,164 reviews
  13. 13

    32 North

    Rosedale, Queens · Restaurant

    4.92,931 reviews
  14. 14

    Laghman Express

    Borough Park, Brooklyn · Halal restaurant

    4.92,779 reviewsGrade B
  15. 15

    787 Coffee

    Mott Haven, Bronx · Coffee shop

    4.92,744 reviewsGrade A
  16. 16

    Gulp

    Long Island City, Queens · Taiwanese restaurant

    4.92,716 reviews
  17. 17

    The Loft Steakhouse

    Borough Park, Brooklyn · Steak house

    4.92,691 reviewsGrade A
  18. 18

    Bareburger

    Upper West Side, Manhattan · Hamburger restaurant

    4.92,674 reviewsGrade A
  19. 19

    Mira Mediterranean & Hookah Lounge

    Kips Bay, Manhattan · Mediterranean restaurant

    4.92,504 reviews
  20. 20

    Dagg Thai Restaurant

    Murray Hill, Manhattan · Thai restaurant

    4.92,444 reviews
  21. 21

    Brick City Vegan Newark (Formerly known as Urban Vegan)

    Mariners Harbor, Staten Island · Vegan restaurant

    4.92,386 reviews
  22. 22

    Talkin' Tacos New York

    Washington Heights, Manhattan · Taco restaurant

    4.92,223 reviews
  23. 23

    SAPERAVI

    Gramercy Park, Manhattan · Georgian restaurant

    4.92,112 reviewsGrade A
  24. 24

    Chocolate House Bronx 161

    Concourse, Bronx · Dessert shop

    4.92,019 reviews
  25. 25

    Glatt A La Carte

    Borough Park, Brooklyn · Steak house

    4.91,809 reviews

Best-rated by dietary category

How many qualifying restaurants carry each dietary certification.

vegetarian

59

whole foods

47

halal

32

vegan

22

dairy free

14

kosher

13

gluten free

5

Related data reports

NYC Restaurant Health Grade Report

Analysis of NYC DOHMH inspection grades by borough, neighborhood, and cuisine type.

Read →

Explore all 546 best-rated restaurants

Filter by borough, dietary need, or neighborhood to find your next standout restaurant in NYC.

Browse Grade A restaurants →NYC Health Grade Report