Kosher restaurant
Effy's Cafe
Effy's Cafe in Upper West Side, Manhattan holds NYC DOHMH Grade A (score 5, inspected Dec 2024). It is tagged Kosher. The address on file is 104 W 96th St, New York, NY 10025.
Data through December 2024.
- Grade
- NYC DOHMH Grade A Official NYC DOHMH inspection grade
- Score
- 5
- Inspection date
- 2024-12-02
- Address
- 104 W 96th St, New York, NY 10025
Upper West SideManhattan
Book or order
Upper West Side
Manhattan
The brief
About Effy's Cafe
Effy's Cafe is listed with Upper West Side healthy dining, healthy spots across Manhattan and kosher-friendly restaurants in NYC.
Health inspection
NYC DOHMH Grade A
Official NYC DOHMH inspection grade
Score5(lower is better)
Inspected12/2/2024
Grade A means this score of 5 falls in the 0–13 point band. Grade A means fewer than 14 points on the initial inspection or the reinspection. A letter grade is not a taste rating and is not a dietary claim.
NYC DOHMH
Inspection record
Effy's Cafe's latest NYC DOHMH inspection on file on December 2, 2024 shows Grade A, score 5. Lower scores are better. This is the most recent inspection we hold. We do not store earlier visits, so we cannot show a trend.
Among 43 other graded restaurants in Upper West Side, the average inspection score is 11.6. Effy's Cafe's score of 5 is 6.6 points lower.
Effy's Cafe scored 5. That is 5.6 points lower than the 10.6 average for 40 other graded restaurants listed as Kosher restaurant.
Last inspection date on file: .
Grade A restaurants near Effy's Cafe
- Talia's Steakhouse and Bar · 0.2 mi · Grade A · score 7 · Feb 2026 · kosher · 4.3/5
- Noi Due Cafe · 0.6 mi · Grade A · score 11 · Jan 2024 · kosher · 4.6/5
- Jacob's Pickles · 0.1 mi · Grade A · score 12 · Dec 2025 · 4.5/5
- Bareburger · 0.1 mi · Grade A · score 9 · Dec 2025 · 4.8/5
FAQ
Effy's Cafe
Grade A, from its December 2, 2024 NYC DOHMH inspection (score 5).
December 2, 2024. That is the latest inspection we hold.
5 is in the A band. A covers 0–13 points, B 14–27, and C 28 or more.
Yes. We tag it kosher because the restaurant identifies that way or has substantial menu coverage.
104 W 96th St, New York, NY 10025, Upper West Side, Manhattan.
Monday 8AM-9PM; Tuesday 8AM-9PM; Wednesday 8AM-9PM; Thursday 8AM-9PM; Friday 8AM-9PM; Saturday 8AM-9PM; Sunday 8AM-9PM. Hours are as listed; confirm before visiting.
4.4/5 from 662 Google reviews.
Talia's Steakhouse and Bar (0.2 mi), Noi Due Cafe (0.6 mi), Jacob's Pickles (0.1 mi).
Community Rating
4.4
out of 5
662 community reviews
Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.
Been here? Share one sentence.
No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.
Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?
Explore
Effy's Cafe is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Manhattan, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.
Explore more
Find similar spots
Weekly email
Grade A Eats This Week
Grade A picks, new openings, and diet-friendly finds. One email a week. What you get