American restaurant

Pershing Square

Murray HillManhattan

4.2· 4,761 reviewsClosed now
Pershing Square — american restaurant — in Murray Hill — Manhattan — NYC
Pershing Square interior — Murray Hill

Murray Hill

Manhattan

The brief

About Pershing Square

Located across from Grand Central Terminal, this American bistro bustles day & night.

Community Rating

4.2

out of 5

4,761 community reviews

Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.

Community-sourced rating

Reviews

What diners say about Pershing Square

15 verified Google reviews

4.4

15 reviews

5
10
4
2
3
2
2
1
1
0
Ryan RobbinsLocal guide
a week ago

Absolutely perfect we arrived at 11 and wanted lunch. It didn't start for another 30 minutes apparently but they bumped up the time for us so we didn't wait long. The waiting a staff was absolutely accommodating along with my family and grandchildren. I had the chicken pot pie which I had to have in a long time as good as my grandmother made. Don't pay attention to the wait times reviews because we went right in and got seated

Gerald LongjohnLocal guide
3 weeks ago

Thoroughly enjoyed breakfast at this classic spot across the street from Grand Central Station! The atmosphere takes you back to a more distinguished time without being pretentious and the service is attentive and friendly. The food presentation is first rate and fresh orange juice and plentiful coffee were both excellent!

Tim Beecher
4 weeks ago

We stopped here for a late dinner this past week and we had a great experience. The staff were very attentive, knowledgeable and pleasant. The menu was diverse, and the food was very fresh. Everyone cleaned their plates. The place is large, with plenty of seating and an outdoor patio as well. We heard their breakfasts are amazing as well.. We would recommend this place.

Michelle SaxtonLocal guide
3 months ago

We stumbled across this restaurant as we were passing and so glad we went in. The staff were so lovely. The food was excellent. I had the lobster roll (delicious!) and my daughter had the short rib beef which she really enjoyed. It was such a great vibe and the service was great!

Julie Warwick
4 months ago

We visited this restaurant for breakfast during our first visit to New York City. They have amazing fresh squeezed orange juice. I had the eggs Benedict and they were very good. My daughter had an omelette and she enjoyed it very much. The service was a bit slow, but they were busy so it was understandable.

Laura TruaxLocal guide
4 months ago

We were looking for a late lunch spot. This place caught our attention and we were quickly seated in a great window booth.<br><br>Service was quick -- there were few other diners at our off-hour mid-afternoon craving. We ordered a chicken bacon club to split along with a salad and fries.<br><br>The ordering was the high point. Well, the fries were those yummy thin fries that arrived pretty hot, screaming Eat Me! The sandwich had no flavor. I mean: At All. Maybe I tasted some wheat in that bread. Maybe not. Salt helped. But it was lacking any semblance of real food.<br><br>Meanwhile, in our great booth seat we watched the cascading line outside of Los Tacos No. 1. Even mid-day that place was hopping. I doubt we would have gotten such a great place to sit, but we would have likely eaten food that had some umph to it.<br><br>So...go for drinks! Or maybe the breakfasts others rave about. But in my experience, this in decidedly not the spot for an off-hours lunch.

James MurphyLocal guide
4 months ago

The End of an Era (insert tear here!)<br>As a frequent visitor to Grand Central Terminal, I have been dining at Pershing Square Cafe for more than 20 years. I order the same thing every time, the pancakes, because they are (were) literally the best I have ever had! They even used to have a small, unadorned sign saying "World's Best Pancakes" in the front window. Unlike the "best coffee" sign in Elf, this statement was true! But today, I found out that they no longer serve this New York treasure. I was given an order of pancakes that I could get at any local diner or bagel shop. Instead of the thin, delicate, yet fluffy ones they always served, I received very plain, thick pancakes, and to add possible injury (salmonella) to insult, they were undercooked! I sent them back and got the waffle instead, which was "meh." If anyone out there was an aficionado of these classic PSC pancakes, please add your voice here, or write your congressperson! This aggression will not stand. I will attach photos of the ridiculous and the sublime (The one with the powdered sugar is the original. They even took away the powdered sugar now!)

Paul PaterakisLocal guide
4 months ago

Eggs Benedict, Two Eggs Over Easy w/ Corned Beef Hash, and Coffee.<br><br>Food/Value: A<br>Service/Wait Time: A<br>Decor/Environment: A<br>Parking: N/A<br><br>Cash/Credit Cards: Yes<br><br>*Photos by me<br><br>Follow me on Instagram: @paulpaterakis<br><br>Tip me in Bitcoin: bc1q38ct2rawwn7jkg5ays5zvycxp8mj69e5q0zp2n

David Barber
5 months ago

Our favorite place for breakfast, brunch and lunch in Midtown. We’ve been dining here for 25 years and they never let us down.<br><br>My wife’s favorite is the Egg Benedict with Salmon. My go to is French Toast in the morning hours or a burger in the afternoon.<br><br>Atmospheres is amazing, service is always solid and the location can’t be beat.

Ree ALocal guide
5 months ago

The waffle was soft and tasty, but the downside is that it wasn’t crispy as expected.<br>Prices are slightly on the higher side, however the service was fast and there was no waiting time, which is a big plus.<br>Overall, a good experience and a nice spot for a quick, relaxed breakfast.

Sixing ZhaLocal guide
6 months ago

Best breakfast we had during our stay in NYC! We ate here the morning before flying out. They kindly stored our luggage while we ate. Our server was very nice and brought our food SUPER fast! All food was expertly prepared and delicious 😋 The Oatmeal and eggs benedict were amazing. Definitely get a booth with a window on either side of the restaurant to watch the passers-by!

Jennie van WyngaardtLocal guide
7 months ago

Came in the day before for a take away coffee which was really good. Decided to return as I'm craving a sit down meal after traveling. At first the eggs where under cooked, they fixed it but left me with over salted dry and chewy bacon. Go for the coffee but skip the rest. It's priced to highly to be bad.

Carly JarusLocal guide
8 months ago

Stopped at Pershing Square for dinner and had a NY Strip with mashed potatoes and a glass of Riesling. The steak was cooked perfectly and topped with a rich red wine sauce. The mashed potatoes were creamy and just right. The staff was attentive and quick, and they made sure to check in to see if everything was to my liking, which I really appreciated. The atmosphere was great, intimate, moody, and not too loud.

Monique le Conge ZiesenhenneLocal guide
9 months ago

Long-time breakfast/brunch spot that I never miss. The blueberry pancakes are just delicious! I also had the Eggs Benedict and hubs had a waffle with bacon and eggs. We both found the food prepared with care. Service was friendly and responsive to any special requests. Nice location when you're near Grand Central Station. Have been here many times and always look forward to going back.

Kim MontalvoLocal guide
9 months ago

My first time at Pershing Square and I was not disappointed! I ordered the fettuccine pasta with vegetables in a pesto sauce for lunch and it was amazing. The portion was generous and I ate the whole thing! Food baby! The service was great. As a matter fact, we had several servers and they were all very polite, friendly. Decent prices too. My entreé was $22. The only thing I didn’t care for was how loud it was! Overall, I highly recommend Pershing Square for a business lunch, out with friends, maybe not a first date if you want to talk and get to know each other.

Reviews sourced from Google. Displayed for informational purposes. Ratings reflect reviewer opinions at the time of posting.

Been here? Share one sentence.

No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.

0/280

Anonymous · Reviewed before publishing

Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?

Explore

Pershing Square is one of many healthy restaurants in our directory. See healthy restaurants in Murray Hill, Manhattan restaurants by health grade, and NYC restaurant health inspection grades.

Pershing Square is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Manhattan, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.