This place was so nice! This was my first time here & our waiter Fabio was so kind and attentive to us even when we were sitting outside. Great vibe, food was great & I will definitely be back !
American restaurant
BOTA Supper Club
St. GeorgeStaten Island
St. George
Staten Island
The brief
About BOTA Supper Club
BOTA Supper Club is an exceptional American restaurant located in the charming St. George neighborhood of Staten Island, earning an impressive 4.9-star rating from 740 satisfied diners. The restaurant specializes in contemporary American cuisine crafted with a focus on quality ingredients and refined technique, while accommodating various dietary preferences and health-conscious choices. BOTA offers an upscale yet welcoming dining atmosphere perfect for special occasions and intimate gatherings, combining sophisticated ambiance with warm hospitality that keeps guests returning for memorable culinary experiences.
Community Rating
4.9
out of 5
740 community reviews
Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.
Reviews
What diners say about BOTA Supper Club
15 verified Google reviews · 14 with owner responses
4.8
15 reviews
- 5★
- 14
- 4★
- 0
- 3★
- 0
- 2★
- 1
- 1★
- 0
First restaurant was beautifully designed, I love that there’s two different spaces. You can tell that a lot of thought was put into the decor. My friends and I are in love! This is a perfect spot for birthdays, or a date or just to eat it’s just the spot lol. We really enjoyed the food all as well and I love that they have different tea options. Highly recommend and will be back! I love the name too. Shout out to 🇦🇱♥️
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for such a thoughtful and enthusiastic review! We’re thrilled to hear you and your friends enjoyed the atmosphere, decor, food, and tea selection. A lot of love and intention went into creating both spaces, so it truly means a lot to hear that it stood out to you. We’re honored to be considered a spot for celebrations, date nights, and everyday moments alike! Thank you again for the recommendation, and we can’t wait to welcome you back soon.
absolutely amazing, service, food and atmosphere, we came here for our anniversary dinner and it was perfect, every single thing we ate was delicious, the small plates, the entrees, down to the cocktails, baddest of them all was so good, the lemon creme brulee for dessert, truly amazing. we couldn’t recommend this place enough
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for celebrating your anniversary with us! We’re honored to have been part of such a special occasion and thrilled to hear every part of your experience — from the small plates and cocktails to the lemon crème brûlée — made the evening memorable. We’ll definitely share your compliments with our team. Your recommendation truly means the world to us, and we can’t wait to welcome you back again soon!
Took my daughter here for lunch for her birthday. We had the pleasure of having Sergio as our server. He was very attentive. The drinks he made were delicious. We had the lychee cocktail. Food was great and the atmosphere was definitely a vibe. Only issue is this is only wine/champagne, beer only.
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for sharing your wonderful experience with us! We're thrilled to hear that you chose to celebrate your daughter's birthday at our establishment and that Sergio took great care of you both. It’s always rewarding to hear that our drinks, especially the lychee cocktail, were a hit! <br><br>We appreciate your feedback regarding the beverage options, and we understand how having more variety can enhance the dining experience. Your insights are invaluable as we strive to create an enjoyable atmosphere for our guests. <br><br>We hope to have the pleasure of welcoming you and your daughter back soon to create more memorable moments together!<br><br>
I was immediately greeted, asked if I have reservations even though the place was empty but I heard this place gets packed so I told the young lady I didn't. She asked it's my first time there and I replied yes. I was offered to sit upstairs or downstairs which looked huge.i preferred to sit on the first floor since it was more dim for my liking. I went to use the restroom and when I came back I was given bread with sauce and a round breaded item. I sat down and another gentleman inflated this bubble and popped some warm smoke on the round breaded cheese which was also on some sweet sauce, it was so tasty. I did try the bread with the sauce. The sauce was delicious, the bread wasn't to my liking since it wasn't crispy and had a unique flavor I'm not sure if it tasted old or the flavor. I was offered a variation of water but I chose tap, I ordered hibiscus passion fruit cocktail, Mac and cheese with the lollipop chicken wings. I believe riskybiscui7 ratings and I've already heard great things about this restaurant especially that Sergio is the best chef. I'm not a, fan of Mac and cheese but let me tell you Sergio got talent for this, it's his destiny. The food was amazing and his wife who I met yesterday is a wonderful person very sweet. I saw other 2 ladies coming in after, one of them had an issue with the drink being too sweet or something on a young server. The lady who's Sergio wife stepped in to help, I'm glad it was resolved. I'm sorry if you guys have to deal with difficult customers, that customer could've asked about the drink before ordering it. I like mine and in the menu it states it's citrus, mine wasn't overpowering nor sweet. I mean I was treated like a Queen in there. I've been to many places in SI and this place and St Marks Cafe are great,,I heard it has the same owner. Clean, great service, fresh food. I definitely recommend everyone to come. BTW Sergio i hope one day you have your own restaurant cause man you have talent for food. God bless everyone who's at Bota, I left and the door was open for me I felt like I was walking out of the most fanciest places in NYC! One thing I have to add and this comment is for a positive, please provide a straw if the drink is to the top cause I spilled some of it on myself when I raised the glass to drink from it and warn the customer the glass is full. Thank God I have Oxi clean at home and the stain came off my blouse. I didn't say anything cause it was a very positive experience and I want to give suggestions. Thank you all again for making it a pleasant evening for myself
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for taking the time to share such a detailed and heartfelt review! We’re truly honored that you chose to dine with us for your first visit and that you felt so well taken care of from the moment you arrived.<br><br>We’re delighted to hear how much you enjoyed the food and overall experience—especially the special touches at the table and your kind words about Sergio. We’ll be sure to share your compliments with him and the rest of the team, including his wife, who will be so happy to know she made a positive impression as well.<br><br>We also really appreciate your honest feedback regarding the bread and your helpful suggestion about providing straws and a heads-up for full glasses. Insights like yours help us continue to improve and elevate the guest experience.<br><br>Thank you again for your recommendation and for your thoughtful words. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon for another wonderful evening!
We had such a fantastic time and our server Fabio gave use the absolute best service. They had a peaky blinders dinner and a movie downstairs and upstairs had the dinner and bar. Decoration is so modern and detailed. A Dj was killing it after the movie was playing and it was only a Tuesday night. Definitely will be back!
Response from the owner
Thank you for your kind words!
HIDDEN TREASURE ALERT! :) my wife and I were walking past this place and it's so unassuming when you look at it from the outside but when we went inside the hostess named Marie showed us around and we simply could not believe what we were looking at!<br><br>It's like one of those places where you see a modest storefront and door but when you open it up it reveals this incredible dining room!!!<br><br>We only quickly went in there for a drink to check it out as we live in the neighborhood but we are definitely coming back. The St George area definitely needs more places like this and I believe the owners of this place are going to be opening up more establishments. I hope the photos speak for themselves!!! There is no way you can guess what's on the inside just by looking on the outside and I highly recommend this place!!
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for your glowing review! We're thrilled to hear that you and your wife discovered our hidden gem and enjoyed your experience with Marie. It’s wonderful to know that our interior exceeded your expectations, and we’re glad you felt at home right away.<br><br>We truly appreciate your support for the St George area, and we can’t wait to welcome you back for more than just a drink! Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we’re excited for you to explore everything we have to offer. <br><br>See you soon!
Had a lovely dinner here Saturday night with my husband before the theatre (St George is a few minutes walk) the service was friendly and attentive. We sat at the bar and ordered oysters. Calamari and spicy tuna. My husband had a spritz and I had a rose. All very good. Oysters especially. And the calamari was perfectly tender and crispy. One interesting thing is they don’t serve spirits. But it’s nice to have something different once in a while like wine and spritz. We will definitely be back. The decor is beautiful too
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We are thrilled to hear that you and your husband enjoyed a lovely dinner with us before the theatre. It’s great to know that you found our service friendly and attentive, and we appreciate you highlighting the oysters and calamari – we take great pride in our menu offerings!<br><br>We aim to create a unique experience, and we're delighted that our wine and spritz selection added to your evening. Your compliments on our decor mean a lot to us, too! We can't wait to welcome you back for another memorable dining experience. <br>
Great place, delicious food and amazing atmosphere. Sergio was my waiter and he really took care of us. Was super attentive and thoughtful, 10/10 food and environment (also great DJ and vibe 😄)<br><br>Would 100% come again 🤩
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for the amazing review! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed the food, atmosphere, and music—and that the DJ helped set the vibe 😄. Sergio will be so happy to know he took great care of you and made your experience even better. We truly appreciate your support and hope to welcome you back again soon!
So there was no heat or they were waiting for a part. The staff and Owners went above and beyond to make it comfortable portable heaters paid for our dinner. They were extremely nice and couldn't be more helpful and accommodating. I found this place by accident googling French onion soup. it's been there for almost 2 years. They have another café down the block, The meatball appetizers were phenomenal so was the French onion soup. Our waiter was Sergio. He was Outstanding Went above above and beyond even the food we took home was nicely wrapped and decorated.
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for sharing your experience with us! We truly appreciate your understanding and are grateful you gave us the opportunity to make you comfortable- we're glad that the heaters helped. It means a lot to hear such kind words about our team and ownership., and we'll be sure to pass along the praise to Sergio for going above and beyond. We're thrilled you enjoyed the meatballs and French onion soup, and that even your take home was a special touch. Thank you for finding us, and we hope to welcome you back again soon!<br>
Took my mother here last night for 84th birthday. We were seated downstairs and didn't expect to have to keep our coats and hats on for the duration of the dinner. Very cold downstairs and hospitable and never have I ever experience being cold during a dinner inside a restaurant. Fall asleep for the patrons upstairs they were able to benefit from Headt but all we were accommodated were blankets and chili breezes coming from the window. The pricing and the portions did not match. The service were great and tried to accommodate us to the best of their ability, but unless they were heating technicians, they couldn't help us out with the lack of heat. They also hide liquor, but they do serve drinks. It seemed like it was warmer outside than it was downstairs and we couldn't wait to pay the check that already included the tip and had to our cause for warmth. This was a one and done for me and advise any business owner that wants to accommodate people inside a restaurant to make sure your HVAC system is intact
Response from the owner
Thank you for the review!
I was visiting from Charlotte and came across BOTA Super Club on Staten Island — and wow, what an incredible experience.<br><br>Sergio took care of us from the moment we arrived, and honestly, you should ask for him. He has this incredible energy and attitude that makes the whole place feel like home. His service, his attentiveness, and the way he explains each dish turn the night into an experience you’ll always want to come back to.<br><br>The food was spectacular, the music and atmosphere were on point, and the cocktails were amazing. A special shoutout to Augie, the DJ, who set the perfect vibe for the night — his music truly elevated the whole experience.<br><br>Highly recommended — and again, make sure you ask for Sergio. He’s a big part of what makes this place unforgettable.
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for your wonderful review, Natalia! We’re thrilled to hear that you had an incredible experience at BOTA Super Club during your visit to Staten Island. It’s fantastic to know that Sergio made such a positive impact on your evening with his energy and attentiveness. We will certainly pass along your compliments to him, as well as to Augie for his amazing music that helped set the perfect vibe. We appreciate your recommendation and can't wait to welcome you back for another unforgettable night!
What a fun night out and delicious dinner!!! Fabio was our server and treated us exceptionally well and made us feel super special :-) the chef Sergi did not miss a thing. Super wonderful night that I had a recommend to anyone in the area. Even worth the adventure from Manhattan ;-)
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful review! We’re thrilled to hear you had such a fun night out and that both Fabio and Chef Sergi made your evening extra special. It means the world to us that you’d recommend Bota — and we love that you found it worth the trip from Manhattan! We can’t wait to welcome you back for another unforgettable night.
Best dining experience on Staten Island! We popped in just for a quick lunch and were delighted with the friendly and accommodating service! The food and atmosphere is fantastic. Our server Fabio was very nice and food was excellent and very reasonably priced. Five stars all around.
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for this amazing review! We’re thrilled to hear that you had such a fantastic experience, from the warm service to the delicious food and atmosphere. Fabio will be so happy to know he made your visit special. We can’t wait to welcome you back to Bota for another five-star experience!
Best experience ever! The food was absolutely delicious with generous portions. They went above and beyond to make my friend’s birthday so special and truly memorable. Our host, Sergio, was outstanding—warm, attentive, and made the night perfect. Highly recommend!
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful review! We’re delighted to hear you had such a memorable experience celebrating your friend’s birthday with us. It’s fantastic that you enjoyed the food and portions, and we’re so glad Sergio helped make the night extra special. We truly appreciate your recommendation and look forward to welcoming you back soon!
Reviews sourced from Google. Displayed for informational purposes. Ratings reflect reviewer opinions at the time of posting.
Been here? Share one sentence.
No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.
Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?
Explore
BOTA Supper Club is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Staten Island, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.