Mexican restaurant

5 Burro Cafe

Forest HillsQueens

4.4· 2,532 reviewsOpen until 1AM
5 Burro Cafe — mexican restaurant — in Forest Hills — Queens — NYC
5 Burro Cafe interior — Forest Hills

Forest Hills

Queens

The brief

About 5 Burro Cafe

Lively local restaurant serving strong margaritas & Mexican fare in a small, funky setting.

Health inspection

NYC DOHMH Grade A

A

Score12(lower is better)

Inspected12/26/2024

Grade A is the highest mark from NYC's Department of Health — about 90% of restaurants earn it.

How grades work

Community Rating

4.4

out of 5

2,532 community reviews

Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.

Community-sourced rating

Reviews

What diners say about 5 Burro Cafe

15 verified Google reviews · 7 with owner responses

3.9

15 reviews

5
8
4
3
3
1
2
1
1
2
Frank
Edited 3 weeks ago

Their food made me very sick. I will avoid this place not worth eating there. The yelp reviews are more accurate. People who ate here say the same thing they got food poisoning.

Juan Diaz
a month ago

We went on a day that was not too busy and the service was still delayed. The food was just ok but the bill was what we'll remember. $30 for 3 tacos and $28 for two burritos. Add drinks and you're at $100 with tip. Cost is relative but when you factor in the service and quality of food - not worth the hype and we will not be returning unfortunately.

Janelle MojicaLocal guide
a month ago

When I first sat down both me and my man wanted to leave only because we thought the food wouldn’t be good, we stayed to give it a chance. Thank god we did! Some of the best Mexican food we both have ever tried, amazing customer service as well! The steak tacos and chicken flautas were sooo good, the tacos were better though. Will be coming back here more often!

Response from the owner

Thank you

Kevin MegnauthLocal guide
3 months ago

Delicious food and good portions. The drinks are nice and strong!

Saleena Ram
3 months ago

The Actual worst Resturant I have ever been to. The service is horrible. All the workers were so horrible and dismissive. I think this restaurant got a little over their heads, they even said I used chat GPT to make my ID???? All the workers seemed drunk there. Sampson was so so rude I never want to return to this restaurant again. Do not recommend. There are so many better places on Austin street to depend your night. Please please do not come here.

linaaveyaLocal guide
6 months ago

YUM. The protein is really high quality. Shrimp was super fresh. Skirt steak fajitas slightly chewy but that’s probably cause I got them rare. Very delicious.

Lee GregoryLocal guide
7 months ago

Always good stuff I’m surprised by now after all the years that I’ve been here (10+) I haven’t left a review. I always come back here whether it is just me or with a couple of others. Guess my lil secret

Carly PisarriLocal guide
11 months ago

Popped in for a late lunch with a friend on a 100 degree day. It was so nice and cool in there, it was incredibly refreshing. I had the pulled pork tacos and they were amazing. The grilled veggies were cooked perfectly. I asked several times for no salt on my rim and it came w salt. What can you do. This place was cute, thanks for having us!

Response from the owner

Thank you. Sorry about the salt!

Mark SotoLocal guide
a year ago

I give this place 5.0 .The food in this place was really great. I totally forgot or underestimated the flavor within the Food. The chips 3.9 were good plus the sauce 4.3(unique). The appetizer: Avocado Relleno - which has shrimp in this wonderful cilantro sauce 4.8. Then there was The Fajitas Combo with steak 5, shrimp 5, and chicken 4.9, which was marvelously flavorful. Rice 3.8, beans, 3.9 And who could forget my son’s Quesadilla Chipotle Chicken 4.8

Response from the owner

Thank you for the great review!!!

Denise A.Local guide
a year ago

We visited after too long of an absence and thanked our lucky stars as we got seated right away at this popular and bustling cafe! Even the hostess told us this was our lucky night as there is always a wait to get in. Yippee!<br>While the place is on the small side and gets a bit cramped, it is such a a unique and welcoming place that allows you to feel instantly comfortable and relaxed.<br>While 5 Burro's is well known for their frozen margaritas (they are fantastic) we opted for some Corona's (no draft beers, only bottles) and tequila shots.<br>Complementary chips and salsa were bright to the table.<br>We ordered the Mexican salad con carne with skirt steak-- a favorite go to that I have never gotten better anywhere. Their in house made dressing makes it so good. All was fresh and delicious.<br>We loved picking some tunes to play on the jukebox.<br>Service was super friendly and attentive. The restrooms were clean and well maintained.<br>On street parking only.<br>Can't wait to come back.

Response from the owner

Thank you!!

Grace Hyeri Chung JiLocal guide
a year ago

Good place to have a big meal and enjoy with your friends and family. Food tasted delicious. The portion of the food was big enough for a person. Had leftovers to take home for later snack. The atmosphere is perfect for casual dining. The restaurant was quite cold. It was a cold rainly day. The service was alright, although we had to wait for the waiter for a long time to get our check. The gratuity 20% was already included for Friday early dinner time at 5 for 4 people. Note: Lunch and dinner price is different, the portion of the food is different for lunch and dinner.

Nicollette KaczmarekLocal guide
2 years ago

Great Mexican food and even better drinks! The Margaritas here are STRONG. Some of the best I’ve had! I was impressed with their chicken fajitas and quesadillas. The chicken nachos were ok, but a little burnt. I wouldn’t get them again. But everything else was excellent. Would definitely recommend this place!

Response from the owner

Thank you. Next time try the steak nachos.

Robert ReynoldsLocal guide
2 years ago

I followed the hype to try this spot. I can say I was pretty disappointed in the food. I don’t like that the burritos only have meat and guacamole and everything else is on the side. Then when I try to add stuff to the tortilla, it becomes too big and falls apart. Idk. Maybe next time I’ll try a different dish. But the atmosphere of the place was great. I really loved the vibe. Service was pretty good too. I’ll try it again one day.

Response from the owner

Thanks for the review. We don’t do the California style burrito. Maybe get a fajita next time. Or try our tacos. Anything with skirt steak won’t disappoint. 😀🌮

Nonna StarrLocal guide
2 years ago

This is my go to for frozen margaritas and an excellent skirt steak salad 🥗 mmmmh<br><br>It’s a little on the small side so if you’re not a fan of cramped spaces this may not be for you. They do have our door seating. If your lucky you won’t have to wait long to be seated. The frozen margaritas are delicious and they offer a host of flavors. The staff is friendly and portions are perfect. This is a perfect chill, eat and drink spot. You will not be disappointed.<br><br>If it’s your birthday let the waiter know and you’ll get your very own sombrero hat.

Albert HusmilloLocal guide
2 years ago

Probably the best steak tacos I’ve had! It’s a nice little Mexican spot in Forest Hills and it’s always packed especially on the weekends. Loved the frozen margaritas as well (I do prefer the strawberry one). The steak tacos were cooked medium and it was just amazing, I had to come back the following week just to have it again. The service takes a bit of time but the food is worth it. They also give out free homemade salsa and chips which were really good too! Staff were nice and checks in on you as well. Highly highly recommend! Get the steak tacos. Take my word for it!

Response from the owner

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

Reviews sourced from Google. Displayed for informational purposes. Ratings reflect reviewer opinions at the time of posting.

Been here? Share one sentence.

No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.

0/280

Anonymous · Reviewed before publishing

Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?

Explore

5 Burro Cafe is one of many healthy restaurants in our directory. See healthy restaurants in Forest Hills, Queens's healthy dining scene, and NYC restaurant health inspection grades.

5 Burro Cafe is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Queens, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.