Umi Premium Sushi & Seafood Buffet

Party of 10 adults and 3 children. Our bill was over $600, yet the experience from start to finish was terrible.<br><br>The first issue was being charged full adult price for children who clearly did not qualify as adults under the restaurant’s own policy. The male host immediately insisted my niece and nephew were teenagers when they were not. Not only were they not teenagers, they were also well under the 4-5 foot height requirement. To avoid creating a scene and because we’d already waited a long time for seating, I reluctantly let it go.<br><br>Things only got worse when it came time to pay. We paid $400 cash and the remainder by card. Due to fraud protection from earlier purchases that day, my bank temporarily declined the card. Instead of handling the situation professionally, the staff came back with rude attitudes and treated us like we were trying to skip out on the bill even though our entire party was still seated at the table. I immediately resolved the issue and paid what was owed.<br><br>Meanwhile, the kids went to pick up their boba tea, and while we were still within the restaurant’s stated two-hour limit, the same host aggressively informed them we’d have to pay extra. At that point, it felt less like customer service and more like harassment.<br><br>To top it all off, much of the food and fruit appeared stale, and the service was some of the worst I’ve experienced. The male host and the woman at the register were consistently rude, dismissive, and unprofessional.<br><br>What bothered me most wasn’t the money it was the complete lack of respect. When a party spends over $600 in less than 2hrs, basic courtesy should not be too much to expect. We left feeling targeted, unwelcome, and disrespected. We will never return and will not be recommending this establishment to anyone. Nostrand Location!!

This place is def NOT a premium buffet and they falsely advertised on social media that they would have unlimited lobster in garlic sauce until 5/31. I got there and paid the extra money and was only allowed one whole lobster and they cooked it with the rubber bands on the claws which makes the whole lobster taste like toxic rubber. All the food is dried out and i went there 6pm on a Saturday, and all their sushi rolls either has egg or cream cheese in them so they are cheap and lots of rice. Def not worth the $55. Complete rip-off. Avoid this place.

$45.99 per person for the lobster buffet dinner. I thought it would be unlimited based on the ad, but it wasn't. The lobster wasn't grilled either—it was boiled and chewy.<br><br>Overall, the buffet was not good. They automatically added a tip—well, they called it a "service charge," not a tip. Lol. I wonder why, because the server was nowhere to be found most of the time. The service was terrible.<br><br>I will not be returning. The locations in New Jersey and Staten Island are way better.

Umi buffet has an amazing selection of food and desserts - I am always happy whenever I come here! Fruits, seafood, grilled meats, and yummy desserts. There's also a selection of ice cream & bubble tea! Make sure to get 5% when you visit.

Found this place while looking for Umi Sushi & Seafood Buffet in google. The one we went to was in Hillside Ave over at Queens, but I wanted to go to a place that was essentially closest to my home.<br><br>That's when I discovered Umi Premium Sushi & Seafood Buffet over by Nostrand Ave. When I looked through the pictures with my friend, I stated the place looked really nice. I even caught my eye on the tree by the entrance. There was an even bigger display of food to choose from, and y'know I had to grab myself some. So I told my parents about this place and they have agreed trying out the buffet.<br><br>Our reaction? Phenomenal. We were satisfied with the service. All the employees that we've met have been so nice throughout the buffet. My family enjoyed it all. Even my brother John Copeland (the one who recently made a review) was really happy on joining us for dinner last time.<br><br>We visited so much that most of the people that work in the buffet knows me and my family. Especially one in particular that always say hi to me. Even though at times I couldn't say Hi back cause I was shy, but I was happy to see that I was being recognized.<br><br>I love their lobster, I always go to the sushi section cause I really love sushi. And whenever I want to go out and eat, I'd always come to eat here. It is so nice!<br><br>Overall, I say 10/10 on everything. Keep up the good work! Love the food, the employees, good atmosphere, it has it all. Despite the parking lot though. I think that's fine granted that this place is nearby Fun Land and Aldi. I also didn't know this place use to have a party city. Oh well <3

This was my favorite add of Umi restaurants I’ve been to I thought they had the tastiest fresh food. The service was amazing being cute. I love getting a hot pot spicy with spicy, but it wasn’t overpowering. It was perfect. Put a whole bunch of vegetables in it I love the refreshing drink.

Yes, have to go beautiful place, good food, good music. Even one more the best part they take EBT yes!!!!

came to Umi today to have a nice lunch break after not eating breakfast today. overall was pretty satisfied with the selection but buffet food will always be buffet food. it’s honestly subpar but easy to make your moneys worth if you come hungry. sushi rice was quite hard and sticky and too much! some pieces not as fresh but for the most part it was alright. overall solid budget option for here in brooklyn. would come back if i want to have a buffet. (btw there was a 1.50 off every adult meal online)

Omg this place when has fell off I’m truly<br>Disappointed; the food look like it sat out all day ; THE OXTAILS NEED TO COOK LONGER TOOO TOUGH , also the rice was dried out salmon was dried out ! The oysters omg ! Again Dried out ; everything look like it was sitting out all day . Again I’m disappointed because this place had amazing food at a point, nevertheless the Soda was the best part of the meal unfortunately

im going to stop coming here. the limited variety is getting very old. quality is good. what they serve is no longer in my best interest for my appetite.<br><br>20250813::place was packed with seniors for an event. had to leave cause of food shortage. :(<br>20250724::im here again for the herbal soup<br>20250606::seriously i have an eating problem<br>20250528::in 13 days. i have a problem<br>20250515::food selection is limited, but still good<br>20250506::i like the sashimi<br>20250425::feed me seymour<br>20250416::7 days since i was here?<br>20250409::i don't go here as often, but its still good<br>20250326:: they don't put out the salmon sashimi often enough<br>20230208::::they are open and now its $19.99<br>20230118::been here several times and its not bad. since its closed. i am going to the one on emmons ave. seafood buffet. not that much variety but the ice cream is great

If you’re searching for the best all-you-can-eat seafood buffet in Brooklyn, look no further than Umi Premium Seafood Buffet on Nostrand Avenue in Sheepshead Bay. This place is an absolute paradise for seafood lovers.<br><br>They serve unlimited fully steamed lobsters 🦞, a full hot pot station, and some of the freshest sushi and sashimi you’ll find in New York City. The buffet is overflowing with crab legs, stone crabs, and garlic Dungeness crabs, plus a full salad bar and a huge variety of sides and dishes — something for everyone.<br><br>What makes Umi Premium Seafood Buffet stand out is the quality and variety. From the sushi counter to the steamed seafood towers, everything tastes fresh, flavorful, and premium. And here’s a major bonus: they have their own parking lot — a huge convenience in the city!<br><br>Whether you’re craving lobster, sushi, sashimi, or piles of crab legs, this spot delivers it all in one place. It’s easily one of the top buffets in Brooklyn and a must-visit for anyone who loves seafood.<br><br>📍 Umi Premium Seafood Buffet – Nostrand Ave, Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, NY<br><br>✅ Perfect for family dinners, date nights, or big group outings<br>✅ Unlimited lobster, sushi, sashimi, hot pot & more<br>✅ Fresh seafood, premium flavors, and convenient parking<br><br>If you want a seafood feast in NYC, this is the place to go.

Really enjoyed my lunch here, ate everything I was craving! Huge selection and constantly replenishing the sections. Great sushi and seafood bar. All the classic Chinese buffet items but what differentiates this place is a full raw bar and full sushi bar that includes sashimi and caviar. All you can eat, unlimited for a very reasonable price for this area highly recommend stopping by for your next lunch, especially if you love to try different foods at the same time like me<br><br>Great value lunch for the area.

I had the pleasure of celebrating Mother’s Day with my family at Umi Premium Buffet, and it was truly an unforgettable experience. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted warmly and seated quickly despite the holiday rush — a clear sign of the restaurant’s well-organized and efficient team.<br><br>What stood out immediately was the amazing variety of food. Umi offers something for everyone: fresh sushi rolls, savory ramen, perfectly cooked seafood, and even comforting soul food options like fried chicken and mac and cheese. Each station was clean, well-stocked, and bursting with flavor. Everything we tried was absolutely delicious — you can tell the chefs care about quality and freshness.<br><br>A special highlight was the Mother’s Day lobster special, which was both generous and incredibly tasty. It added such a luxurious touch to an already impressive buffet and made the day feel even more special. My mother was thrilled — and full!<br><br>The ambiance was modern and comfortable, perfect for both families and larger gatherings. The service team deserves a special shoutout — they were polite, fast, and attentive throughout our entire meal, making sure plates were cleared and drinks refilled without us even needing to ask.<br><br>If you’re looking for a buffet that truly has it all — incredible food, efficient service, and a welcoming atmosphere — Umi Premium Buffet is the place to go. We left happy, satisfied, and already planning our next visit. Highly recommend it for special occasions or any day you want to indulge!

If I could give this place zero stars, I would do it a million times over — but sadly, I’m forced to give it one.<br><br>Let’s talk food — or whatever this excuse for food was.<br><br>The “fortune cookie” arrived already stale, crumbling like dried cardboard, and there wasn’t even a fortune inside. That alone should’ve been the warning. Things only got worse. I tried to salvage the experience with some fruit… but how do you mess up fruit? The orange slices were dry like they’d been sitting out for hours. The cantaloupe? Tasteless and mushy. The honeydew? Like biting into cold, soggy foam.<br><br>Then there was the “dessert” — if you can call it that. A bland, lifeless flan plopped into a sad foil cup, a spoonful of what looked like whipped cream drowning in old chocolate pudding, and a plastic cup of who-knows-what that had clearly given up on life. Nothing tasted fresh. Nothing looked remotely appetizing. Even the drinks were tragic.<br><br>And the price? Absolutely not worth it. Not even if they paid me to eat here. Nothing was delicious, nothing was affordable, and the entire performance — from presentation to flavor — was downright depressing.<br><br>Save your money. Save your tastebuds. Go literally anywhere else. I’ve had gas station snacks more satisfying than this.<br><br>One star because zero isn’t an option!<br>Run away from this place and delete the choice from google map as soon as you can!

I came here with my brother to have a quick lunch. We were welcomed right away with a variety of fresh salads, all types of seafood, sushi, delicious assortment of Chinese and other Asian hot foods. Everything was delicious, fresh and the service was great. I highly recommended Umi Premium Sushi & Seafood Buffet.