Pisillo Italian Panini FIDI

The best sandwich I’ve had in my life (not lying)! Huge sandwich, so it will last awhile. Customer service was great as well!

Pisillo,The best sandwich I've eaten in New York. Quality ingredients. You can choose from different types of bread. Tasty sandwich that can even be shared by two. Welcoming and friendly staff.A little corner of Italy in New York! Thank you...

The little, very authentic Italian sandwich shop is not to be missed. (This one is their flagship.) The staff is super nice, always welcome you to the counter with a big smile. The sandwiches are delicious; if you have no allergies, close your eyes, point your finger to any of the sandwich choices and you won't be disappointed. We try not to visit too often but, at last, once a week isn't so bad, right? 😉

Paninis are great, everyone was Italian. Very authentic little spot. They also gave me espresso on the house. Plus my girl loved it and you can’t beat that. Buenisimo!

Great spot. Best sandwiches not gonna lie but they don't take credit card. So you can order ahead for a pick up on their website or use the ATM in the restaurant. 10/10 would recommend

Killer Italian sandwich. Great bread options made fresh everyday. The semolina was amazing. Seeded on both sides.<br><br>About 30-40 menu choices quality ingredients, fast service.<br><br>The sandwich is literally huge. 20$ but would feed two grown men easy. Great spot for an area that’s not too food friendly. Can’t recommend enough.

I stumbled upon this Italian sandwich shop in New York, and it was an absolute gem. Everything was simply perfect – from the fresh, high-quality ingredients to the authentic flavors that transported me straight to Italy. The bread was warm and crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and the fillings were generous and delicious.<br><br>The staff was friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. The place has a cozy atmosphere, perfect for a quick bite or a relaxed meal.<br><br>If you’re in New York and craving a true taste of Italy, this is a must-visit. Highly recommended!

We were looking for a place to have a quick lunch near the 9/11 Museum and what a great find. The sandwiches are unique, tasty and huuuuge. We shared a Parm sandwich and it filled us both up. Service was friendly and quick. Atmosphere and personable and fun. It made us feel like we were in Italy. Definitely worth stopping by when in Manhattan.

Dayuuummmmmmmm. As you can see pisillo is excellent. This sandwich’s dimensions are approximately LWH 1.5’ x 5” x 4” worth it every time. 4 stars for atmosphere because a group of youngsters walked in and flooded the place with their “vibez”

One of the best sandwiches I've ever had. The ingredients all compliment each other so well and are incredibly fresh. Bread was outstanding. Great portion for the price. Cannot recommend this spot enough.

We had a great time with the sandwich & service!<br><br>Ordered the Pisillo - slightly messy but not at all hard to eat. The sauces dropped everywhere so definitely get extra napkins. Amazing bread and fillings. If the sauces could get soaked by the bread as we consume, that would be exceptional!<br><br>PS: cash only! Be ready!<br><br>** amazing staff! Exceptional hospitality!

I can say as a Brooklynite, without exaggeration, that this is currently my favorite place to eat food from in NYC. I used to work in this neighborhood, and now that I don't, I still think about these sandwiches at least once a week. I'm not going to claim you'll leave feeling as strongly as I do, but I do believe that if you like Italian sandwiches, you'll be highly satisfied by this place.<br><br>You can't really go wrong with whatever option you go for. My favorite is the Ariccia, but I've tried six or seven of these sandwiches and loved all of them. You're safe to go for whatever you think sounds tastiest to you on the menu. These sandwiches are also big. As someone whose stomach has been called a bottomless pit, eating a full sandwich at a time is doable, but I highly recommend splitting it between two meals or sharing it with someone.<br><br>All in all, I cannot recommend this place highly enough!

Don’t let the little exterior fool you, this place has the BIGGEST and yummiest sandwiches ever. Don’t question it, just go. There can be a long line sometimes. Recommend to order ahead online!<br><br>This is 26. Pisillo ($17.90) - prosciutto di parma, porchetta, bufala mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula, balsamic dressing - on Ciabatta, but they said to get Sfilatino.<br><br>I ate it for 4 meals so worth the money🤗❤️

SUCH quick service and wow!!! The weight of the sandwich for the cost?! Could not believe it! Must’ve weighed at least 5 lbs for 2 sandwiches. We had 26 and 27 for two people and they cut it in thirds for us. We had 2/6 pieces leftover! The quality of the ingredients was five star. You can taste the love that is put into this restaurant! Will definitely be back. There’s no where else like it

Finally decided to check this Italian panini shop. Didn’t realize it was cash only until I got there. There is an ATM machine inside the shop. There’s tables to sit and eat if you’re not doing takeout. It wasn’t as busy on a Saturday afternoon compared to on weekdays. I got #26, one of the top two best sellers here (the other being #5). I chose the sfilatino bread which I kind of regretted and should’ve gotten a bread that was a bit softer. The panini is humongous. Def able to share with another person. The panini was good but not great. Enjoyed the buffalo mozzarella though.