Restaurant

Mustang Harry's

ChelseaManhattan

4.4· 2,483 reviewsOpen until 3AM
Mustang Harry's — restaurant — in Chelsea — Manhattan — NYC
Mustang Harry's interior — Chelsea

Chelsea

Manhattan

The brief

About Mustang Harry's

Sports bar near Madison Square Garden serving drinks & pub grub.

Health inspection

NYC DOHMH Grade B

B

Score19(lower is better)

Inspected12/23/2024

A Grade B means some violations were found. Many B-graded spots earn an A on re-inspection within weeks.

How grades work

Community Rating

4.4

out of 5

2,483 community reviews

Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.

Community-sourced rating

Reviews

What diners say about Mustang Harry's

15 verified Google reviews · 15 with owner responses

4.6

15 reviews

5
9
4
6
3
0
2
0
1
0
Shayla SLocal guide
a month ago

Went during a basketball game, Great food! Well presented meals, waiter was very friendly and helpful! Thank you Sean! The only hicup was the hostess, she denied my entry in assumption I was only there to watch the game. After I asked twice to a second to another hostess, if I can be seated to have dinner, she seemed clearly annoyed, side chatted in front of the guest,very unprofessional and lack of hospitality Aside from this, it was a pleasent experience.

Response from the owner

Shayla, I really appreciate you coming in during the game and I’m glad you enjoyed the food, the presentation, and Sean’s friendly, helpful service. I’m sorry about the experience at the host stand—that’s not the level of hospitality we want anyone to feel, and we’ll be addressing it with the team.

Vincent M.Local guide
a month ago

Went there for a Knicks playoff game. Great lively atmosphere, cold drinks, and an easy spot to watch the game with friends. Didn’t try the food, but the sliders looked decent and service was quick.

Response from the owner

Vincent, thanks for coming by to catch the Knicks game with us—glad you enjoyed the lively atmosphere, cold drinks, and how easy it was to watch with friends. Happy to hear the service was quick too, and next time you’ll have to give those sliders a try.

Jes JonLocal guide
2 months ago

Pulled up after a hockey game at MSG. Excellent location in midtown for a meal/drink pre-event or post-event after the garden. We were seated within 5 minutes. I was concerned, given the crowd after a game, that service would be slow. That was the opposite. We were given menus and seen by a server all within 2 minutes of being seated. The full sleeve of sliders, wings, and disco fries had my table watering over the savoriness. Washed it down with some cocktails to cap the night. 9.7/10

Response from the owner

Jes, really glad you stopped by after the game—being close to MSG is exactly why we love serving that pre- and post-event crowd. I’m happy we got you seated fast and kept the service moving, and it’s awesome to hear the sliders, wings, and disco fries (plus cocktails) hit the spot.

Joseph IaconoLocal guide
3 months ago

Great atmosphere and excellent service! We really enjoyed the food quality and the overall vibe of the place.<br>However, a few pricing issues held it back: the fried calamari appetizer was a very small portion for the price, and charging nearly the same price as the dish just to add chicken or steak to the nachos—bringing them close to $30—is a bit ridiculous. Also, $4.50 for a soda felt steep.<br>Solid spot, but the upcharges for basic add-ons are definitely excessive.

Response from the owner

Hi Joseph, thank you for the detailed and thoughtful review. We’re really glad to hear you enjoyed the atmosphere, service, food quality, and overall vibe.<br><br>We also appreciate the honest feedback on pricing and portions. Comments like yours are genuinely helpful, especially when they call out specific items and add-ons that didn’t feel like a fair value. We’ll be sure to share this with our team and take a closer look.<br><br>Thanks again for taking the time to write such a balanced review.

David Pedersen
3 months ago

Ribeye steak sandwich was a bit one of the best steaks I’ve ever eaten. Lobster pot pie was very good. Service was good only in New York for a couple days but will probably go back.

Response from the owner

David, I’m thrilled you loved the ribeye steak sandwich and thought it was one of the best steaks you’ve ever had, and I’m glad the lobster pot pie hit the spot too. Thanks for the kind words about the service—hope you can make it back to Mustang Harry’s next time you’re in New York.

Max O'Leary
4 months ago

I arrived hoping to watch a Liverpool Football match, they put it on a TV for me. Sat at the bar, ordered a beer and American Breakfast. Watched the game, watched more sports, had more beers, ate a Fish n Chips. The stagf were amazing! And after 5 hours of enjoying the place, I went home.

Response from the owner

It's awesome to hear you had such a great time with us, Max! We're glad you enjoyed the game on TV and appreciated our American Breakfast and Fish n Chips. The staff aims to make every visit enjoyable, and it sounds like they hit the mark during your long stay!

Valentina NobiliLocal guide
4 months ago

One of the best places we've been during our stay in NY! The place is huge, the atmosphere is awesome, the food is soooo delicious, the beers are great and the staff is absolutely friendly. Personally I've eaten the best burger of my life (and probably the biggest one too 😂). Particularly recommended for NBA fans on a game night, if you can't get in the stadium than that's the place to be 😉

Response from the owner

I'm so glad you had such a fantastic time at Mustang Harry's, Valentina! It sounds like you really enjoyed our atmosphere and our burgers, especially with all that energy on game nights. We loved having you, and hope to welcome you back to try more delicious dishes and beers soon!

Joe ListaLocal guide
4 months ago

Food was really good. I was introduced to the hanger cut of steak, and wow was it good.<br><br>Service was great. I was told they weren’t showing the ufc fight, but after asking my waitress to see what she could do, she made it happen for us.<br><br>Really good food , drinks and atmosphere. I will definitely be returning for the hanger steak frites!!

Response from the owner

It's awesome to hear that you enjoyed the hanger steak and had a great experience with our service, Joe! We're glad our team could make the UFC fight happen for you. Looking forward to seeing you back for more steak frites and good times!

Audrey DooceyLocal guide
4 months ago

My go to spot when in Manhattan and my go to recommendation for anyone travelling to NYC! Happened upon the place several years ago when walking by and looking for a place to eat, the owners recognised my accent and they knew where I was from! Food, beverages and staff have all been 5 star on my many visits to Mustang Harry's!

Response from the owner

Happy to hear we're your favorite spot in Manhattan, Audrey! It's great that you stumbled upon us, and we could recognize your accent to make you feel at home. We love knowing our food, drinks, and staff have made every visit enjoyable for you!

Frank PLocal guide
6 months ago

Nice place.<br>Good food.<br>Plenty of seating.<br>The football games were a little loud.

Response from the owner

Hi Frank! I'm glad you enjoyed the food and had a comfortable space to relax. I'll look into the volume during the games—your feedback is super helpful!

Mark KirvenLocal guide
6 months ago

Stopped in here randomly as we were passing by. This place has a nice atmosphere with a good vibe. I tried the short rib grilled cheese sandwich, not a ton of flavor but overall it was good.

Response from the owner

Glad you popped in, Mark! I'm happy you enjoyed the atmosphere and vibe. I appreciate the feedback on the short rib grilled cheese and will definitely keep it in mind for next time. Looking forward to having you back!

Fernando GrahamLocal guide
6 months ago

This bar is right next to MSG and when I visited it was right before a Knicks game. Atmosphere was just like a sports bar but the food was better than expected. Only negative was that the service was pretty slow. Maybe it was too crowded but I waited quite a long time for everything to come out.

Response from the owner

Hi Fernando, I'm glad you enjoyed the food and atmosphere here at Mustang Harry's. Sorry to hear about the wait time; it can get hectic before a game at MSG. Appreciate your patience, and hope to make your next visit even better!

jason molidorLocal guide
6 months ago

We had some drinks and watched the Ravens! A taste of Baltimore right in midtown Absolutely love a bar completely full of Ravens fans. We had a lovely Ukrainian bartender, I cannot remember her name, but she was attentive and friendly. Despite the Ravens poor first half was really positive, and Ravens pulled out a win. Anyway, if you’re from Baltimore and homesick or a big Ravens fan this is a good spot for you. We only had drinks so can’t judge food.

Response from the owner

Sounds like you had a great time with fellow Ravens fans! We’re glad you enjoyed the atmosphere and attentive service from our Ukrainian bartender. Whenever you’re ready to try the food, we’d love to welcome you back!

Daniel Cancian
8 months ago

Hughie was awesome. Said he’s only been rocking the bar for three months!!! Man was crushing service bar and looks like a vet already. I’ve been bartending for 10+ years and this young man definitely impressed me. Cheers and check it out.

Response from the owner

I'm so glad to hear that Hughie made such a strong impression! He’s been a fantastic addition to our team, and your praise means a lot, especially coming from a fellow bartender. Thanks for the shout-out, and I hope you swing by again soon!

HLocal guide
a year ago

The food was really good. Loved the lamb lollipops. We usually love salty food, but felt like the onion soup was way too salty. On the flip salt, the short rib tasted like there was no salt in it at all. Both still very good and not a big deal. The steak was very chewy though. I don’t think I ever had a steak in a restaurant before that was that chewy. They did send out an email the next day checking in, which was a nice touch.

Response from the owner

I’m glad to hear you enjoyed the lamb lollipops and appreciated our follow-up email! I'm sorry to hear the steak didn't meet your expectations, and I'll definitely share your feedback with the kitchen team. We hope to welcome you back to Mustang Harry's again soon for an even better experience.

Reviews sourced from Google. Displayed for informational purposes. Ratings reflect reviewer opinions at the time of posting.

Been here? Share one sentence.

No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.

0/280

Anonymous · Reviewed before publishing

Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?

Explore

Mustang Harry's is one of many healthy restaurants in our directory. See Chelsea healthy dining, healthy spots across Manhattan, and NYC restaurant health inspection grades.

Mustang Harry's is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Manhattan, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.