Deli

Mr. Broadway

MidtownManhattan

4.5· 4,776 reviewsClosed todayKosher
Mr. Broadway — deli — in Midtown — Manhattan — NYC
Mr. Broadway interior — Midtown

Midtown

Manhattan

The brief

About Mr. Broadway

Contemporary deli with a variety of kosher cuisine including sushi, American & Chinese dishes.

Community Rating

4.5

½

out of 5

4,776 community reviews

Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.

Community-sourced rating

Reviews

What diners say about Mr. Broadway

15 verified Google reviews · 8 with owner responses

4.9

15 reviews

5
14
4
1
3
0
2
0
1
0
Shimi Berger
3 weeks ago

Absolutely wonderful experience! Motti is the greatest, he took the best care of my party. The food was fabulous and Chani was the most amazing hostess. The wait staff including Sylvia, Kat and the rest of the crew were friendly, helpful and all around professional. Highly recommended! You won’t regret it.

Samone Blakely
a month ago

Had such an incredible experience at Mr. Broadway. The food was absolutely amazing from start to finish, the atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the service truly stood out. Connie was an exceptional host and made us feel genuinely taken care of the entire time.<br><br>They also helped make the birthday celebration feel really special, which meant a lot. You can tell there’s real attention to hospitality here, not just good food. Definitely one of those places that makes you want to come back again. Highly recommend.

이강우
a month ago

This establishment offers an exemplary culinary experience that masterfully synthesizes gastronomic excellence with an inviting, family-oriented ambiance. The flavor profiles of the dishes were profoundly sophisticated, demonstrating a high level of culinary craftsmanship.<br><br>Furthermore, the value-to-cost ratio is exceptionally favorable; it is rare to encounter such premium quality at such a competitive price point. The overarching atmosphere and service standards were impeccable, culminating in an immensely satisfying visit. I maintain an unconditional intent to revisit, with a commitment level that far exceeds standard expectations. I highly recommend this venue for those seeking both communal warmth and epicurean delight.

Harriet Cabelly
3 months ago

Excellent restaurant in all ways! From the minute you enter, the hostess Chani is the best. I don't know of any restaurants who have someone like her: warm, engaging, personable and most attentive. The food is always excellent. The place is large, spacious and never feels too crowded, even when it's full. A wonderful and most comfortable dining experience. And of course, owner Moti, is great.

Sophie Schogger
3 months ago

Today was our second trip to Mr Baker as we loved it so much the first time! Big shout out to Irma who was so helpful in making a decision from the vast menu.

Response from the owner

We’re so glad you enjoyed your second visit just as much, and we’ll be sure to share your kind words with Irma. She’ll be thrilled to know she helped make your experience even better. We look forward to welcoming you again soon!

Nechama Singer Customer Support Rentals of Distinction
4 months ago

We came into Manhattan absolutely starving and were told that Mr. Broadway is the place to go. From the moment we walked in, we were impressed by the size of the restaurant and the beautiful décor. The atmosphere was warm and inviting right away.<br><br>We were welcomed by lovely hosts who seated us quickly, made us feel comfortable, and were happy to answer any questions we had. The food came out very quickly with no delays at all, which we really appreciated.<br><br>They even treated us to an appetizer meat platter with delicious liver, which was a really nice touch. We enjoyed a variety of dishes, including burgers, schnitzel wrap, filet mignon, steak, salad, and soup, everything was fresh, flavorful, and well prepared.<br><br>All in all, it was a wonderful dining experience, and we would definitely come back again.<br><br>— Ari Calek, Antwerp Belgium

Response from the owner

Thank you, Ari, for such a thoughtful and detailed review.<br><br>We’re so glad your first visit lived up to the recommendation and that you felt welcomed from the moment you walked in. It’s wonderful to hear you enjoyed the atmosphere, attentive service, and that the food came out promptly. We’re especially happy you appreciated the appetizer platter and the variety of dishes you tried.<br><br>We truly appreciate you visiting us from Antwerp and look forward to welcoming you back on your next trip to Manhattan :)!!

Menachem RosenfeldLocal guide
4 months ago

Food is delicious! And big portions!Chani is a true star taking care or everyone and everything thing making you feel like a king!<br>Highly recommend!!!!!

Response from the owner

Menachem, thank you so much for your kind review. Chani is the best! We'll be sure to pass along the compliments to her.

Yair Daykan
4 months ago

Great dining experience! The food was delicious, fresh, and beautifully presented. The service was friendly and attentive, making us feel very welcome from start to finish. The atmosphere is warm and pleasant, perfect for both a relaxed meal and a night out with friends or family. Highly recommended — we will definitely be back.

Response from the owner

Thank you so much for the kind review Yair and please do come back :)

The key man locksmith San AntonioLocal guide
5 months ago

A ballistic experience!<br>A rich menu in the fullest sense of the word. Everything is delicious, clean, and fresh. Excellent service!<br>All food is strictly kosher (Mehadrin).

Response from the owner

Thank you so much for your kind words. We are delighted to hear you enjoyed the food and service. We strive to deliver the best of both at Mr. Broadway! Please visit us again soon :)

Kenda Serlin
5 months ago

Lovely service and perfect food! The cheesecake is a wonderful finish to any meal

Response from the owner

Thank you for your kind review Kenda, the cheesecake is our favorite as well! Please visit us again soon.

Tamir GershovitzLocal guide
5 months ago

The atmosphere was great, a beautiful place with nice design and a pleasant vibe.<br>The service was excellent and very attentive.<br>The food was good, but not at the highest level compared to the overall experience.

Response from the owner

Thank you for your kind words Tamir. We home to see you again soon!

Netanel Sh
5 months ago

An excellent dining experience from start to finish. From the moment we walked in, we were welcomed with genuine warmth and care, which immediately made us feel comfortable and appreciated.<br>The food was delicious, well prepared, fresh, and thoughtfully presented — every dish arrived on time and was a pleasure to eat.<br>The service truly went above and beyond: attentive, patient, and friendly, with a sincere desire to make sure we had a great experience, without feeling rushed or overdone.<br>It’s clear that this place is run by people who truly understand quality hospitality.<br>Definitely a place we’d be happy to return to, and highly recommended to anyone looking for great food and outstanding service

Abraham Braun
6 months ago

We had an amazing experience starting by friendly greetings by chani she is friendly and very welcoming. We were served by the one and only YASSIN who took care of us friendly and professionally.<br>The food was great and nice presented. Great pricing and mostly great vibe.<br><br>We’ll come again soon.

Joel ZipkinLocal guide
8 months ago

new Mr Broadway near Times Square was incredible and surpassed expectations. Large menu so look on website before you go.<br><br>smash burger with cheddar cheese was excellent. double patty with the fake cheddar melted really nicely and pickles.<br><br>farro salad with grilled chicken was pretty basic, but the salad was fresh.<br><br>service was excellent, always had multiple servers in reach.<br>brisket sliders - unexpectedly spicy<br><br>farro salad with grilled chicken

Andrea San Andres
9 months ago

Nakida was amazing. She did great cocktails for me and my friend.<br>The food was 10/10 and big portions. The appetizers were so flavorful. We ordered some burger sliders with some chicken tenders. Highly recommend!

Response from the owner

We can’t thank you enough for the fantastic review! It’s wonderful to know you enjoyed your time with us. See you again soon!<br>

Reviews sourced from Google. Displayed for informational purposes. Ratings reflect reviewer opinions at the time of posting.

Been here? Share one sentence.

No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.

0/280

Anonymous · Reviewed before publishing

Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?

Explore

Mr. Broadway is one of many healthy restaurants in our directory. See Midtown restaurants by health grade, healthy spots across Manhattan, and best kosher restaurants in NYC.

Mr. Broadway is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Manhattan, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.