Juanita GLocal guide
★★★★★a year ago
Hello, my Foodies, so I had a birthday this week and decided to go to Margaritaville in NY. I wasn't that familiar with the menu, so didn't know ahead of time what to expect. I guess I could have just looked it up online! So I wouldn't recommend for a great choice of food options it's mostly like bar food in a way. They did have burgers, seafood, and pasta dish. But it was minimal. Pricing was good and they are better known for their drinks and happy atmosphere. They had a nice decor and I believe they have 2 main floor to eat upstairs and a cute little shop downstairs. They don't offer a free desert for their birthday guests, but they did gather to wish me a Happy Birthday, and we did get a round of tequila shots, so that was nice. Our waiter Anthony was nice and friendly, but he didn't check on us as often as we liked to get refills and perhaps other items as well as the check, we did have to wait a moment to find him. However, it wasn't something that ruined our experience or anything it was still a fun night, and we liked the atmosphere and friendly staff.
Response from the owner
We're honored that you chose us to host your birthday meal, Juanita! It's fantastic that you enjoyed our friendly service and lively atmosphere. While our menu offerings may not have hit the mark for you, we strive to offer tasty island-inspired favorites that transport guests to paradise. Your feedback helps us improve, and we appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. We hope to welcome you back soon and exceed your expectations! -Margaritaville Management Team