Pizza restaurant

LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave)

Midtown EastManhattan

4.9· 943 reviewsClosed now
LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave) — pizza restaurant — in Midtown East — Manhattan — NYC
LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave) interior — Midtown East

Midtown East

Manhattan

The brief

About LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave)

LaVista Pizza on 2nd Avenue in Midtown East serves authentic Italian-style pizza that satisfies both traditional purists and adventurous eaters. The restaurant accommodates various dietary preferences, offering options for vegetarians and those seeking lighter fare without compromising on flavor or quality ingredients. With an impressive 4.9-star rating from nearly 1,000 reviews, LaVista Pizza delivers a welcoming neighborhood atmosphere that balances casual comfort with refined execution, making it an ideal destination for quick lunches, family dinners, or social gatherings with friends and colleagues in Manhattan.

Community Rating

4.9

½

out of 5

943 community reviews

Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.

Community-sourced rating

Reviews

What diners say about LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave)

15 verified Google reviews · 10 with owner responses

4.7

15 reviews

5
13
4
1
3
0
2
0
1
1
sridhar m
2 weeks ago

We ordered buffalo chicken and barbecue chicken pizza. The pizza was full of sauce. The buffalo pizza was so salty and barbecue pizza was so sweet, i didn’t even felt taste of pizza in a single bite.<br>No refund or correction to the order even after feedback. Domino pizza tastes much better than this at half the price….<br>We plan to take slice, cashiers recommended pie… it was a bad experience and disappointed

Response from the owner

Hi Sridhar. Were extremely sorry for this experience. Please give us a call at the store at your earliest convenience so we can get more information on this and make it right for you. Thank you so much!

Maggie HinrichsenLocal guide
2 weeks ago

Classic pizza in an open and welcoming storefront with a few tables to dine in. Mom of extremely picky pizza eaters give all their thumbs up to this NYC pizzeria!<br>The slices on thin crunchy crusts are full of sauces with just the right zest, not too sweet not too tart. My kids who prefer light cheese did not mind these stringy slices. Toppings on their specially slices are generous and sooooo satisfying. Worth the hike from our Grand Central starting point !

Response from the owner

Maggie, your delightful review fills us with joy! We're thrilled to hear that our classic pizza won over your picky eaters and that the thin, crunchy crusts and zesty sauces hit the mark. It’s wonderful to know that our generous toppings made the experience even more satisfying for your family. Thank you for making the hike from Grand Central to visit us at LaVista Pizza – we’re honored to be part of your pizza adventures! Your support means the world to us! 🍕❤️

S TLocal guide
a month ago

Super friendly people, going out of their way to make a happy (vegan) customer. I saw on the online menu that they can make a whole vegan pie and came in hoping they would have vegan slices available. The sign out front advertises vegan cheese, and there is just one vegan pizza (margherita) on the menu. We asked about vegan pizza slices, which they didn't have available, and I was given a price for a 12" plain cheese vegan pizza as the smallest they could do (more than I needed). I asked about adding toppings and was given a price, then opted for just cheese, but then they added a bunch of vegetables at no charge anyway. I hesitate to say this because I don't want everyone to expect it! I won't even go into other details that really made the customer service stand out. My nonvegan friend ate a couple slices after eating his own nonvegan slices and liked them. It was not the best vegan pizza I've had by any means, but it was good crust and overall a decent vegan pizza, and I really appreciate them trying and am sure they are open to suggestions/requests.<br><br>My advice to the restaurant is to have at least one vegan pie out for 'by the slice', clearly labeled 'vegan' in the case, with some interesting toppings. I said I would add this restaurant to HappyCow (vegan food finder app and website), but they have a rule that a restaurant must offer at least 3 options to be listed. It seems like it would be easy enough to mark a few more options on the menu that might already be vegan or could be optionally vegan (any veggie pizza, eggplant hero, lentil/minestrone soup, etc?). Also, the (owner?) mentioned that vegan cheese is expensive, and the pizza came with a lot of it. In my personal opinion, vegan cheese is better used sparingly, or it is too obvious and goopy, unless it's a really high quality cultured vegan cheese. Better to focus on the flavor of the sauce and toppings and use just enough vegan cheese to give a hint of cheesiness. I feel like they could have gotten away with using half the amount of vegan cheese, and used the other half to make a vegan pizza for the case by the slice. Finally, it would really up your game if you had some vegan meat toppings (Beyond sausage, etc.)

Response from the owner

Thank you for your thoughtful and detailed review, S T! We're thrilled to hear that our team went above and beyond to make your experience enjoyable, especially as a vegan customer. Your feedback about having vegan slices available and more options on the menu is invaluable, and we truly appreciate your suggestions. <br><br>We’re glad your non-vegan friend enjoyed the pizza too! We're always looking for ways to improve and your insights will definitely help us enhance our offerings. Thank you for being a part of our LaVista Pizza family and for sharing your experience with the community! We hope to see you again soon!

Lenka ŠubováLocal guide
2 months ago

Everything was excelent! Best pizza margherita i ever had. And staff was so amazing.

Response from the owner

Lenka, your wonderful review brings a smile to our faces! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed the best Margherita pizza and had a fantastic experience with our amazing staff. It's loyal customers like you who inspire us to keep serving up deliciousness. Thank you for being a part of our LaVista Pizza family!

Jeannette Hayden
2 months ago

Amazing pizza! The crust was PERFECT - crispy, buttery, and perfectly thick.<br>We tried ziti, buffalo chicken with ranch and Caesar salad with chicken. All sooo good.

Response from the owner

Jeannette, your amazing review has us beaming with joy! We're thrilled to hear that you loved our pizza crust and enjoyed the ziti, buffalo chicken, and Caesar salad. It's wonderful customers like you who inspire us to keep crafting delicious dishes. Thank you for sharing your experience with us!

Brooke Hargreaves
2 months ago

Amazing pizza and service!! Love the atmosphere! Makes you feel like family for being a stranger lol.

Response from the owner

Brooke, your review truly warms our hearts! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed our pizza and service. Creating a welcoming atmosphere where everyone feels like family is what we strive for. Thank you for being part of our LaVista Pizza community! We can't wait to serve you again soon! 🍕❤️

Caleb BoyerLocal guide
2 months ago

I came here and I got the rainbow slice with my friend and it was divine. Isa gave us an amazing service and made us feel so welcome. I love New York City.

Response from the owner

Caleb, your review brings a smile to our faces! We're thrilled to hear you enjoyed the rainbow slice and that Isa made your experience even more special. It’s wonderful to know you felt the warmth of our pizzeria. Thank you for sharing your love for LaVista Pizza and for being part of our NYC community! We can’t wait to welcome you back for more delicious moments!

Maneily
3 months ago

Amazing pizzas with such a warm and welcoming staff.<br>Even though we had to wait a bit longer than expected for our pizza, they kindly offered us dessert on the house, which was really appreciated.<br>We highly recommend this place — especially the Chicken Bacon Ranch!

Response from the owner

Maneily, your kind words truly warm our hearts! We're thrilled to hear you enjoyed our pizzas and felt welcomed by our team. It’s wonderful to know that the Chicken Bacon Ranch hit the spot for you! We appreciate your understanding about the wait and are glad you enjoyed the dessert on us. Thank you for recommending LaVista Pizza; we can’t wait to serve you again soon!

Paul ConneallyLocal guide
3 months ago

Hicham is a wonderful and charming host and La Vista has a fantastic selection of great, fresh slices with really generous portions and very good value: definitely going back soon!!

Response from the owner

Paul, your kind words truly make our day! We're thrilled to hear that Hicham made your visit special and that you enjoyed our fresh slices and generous portions. It's wonderful customers like you that inspire us to keep serving up delicious pizza. We can't wait to welcome you back soon for another fantastic experience! 🍕✨

Elena DiFante
3 months ago

Great experience!!! Stopped in here with a friend after getting of the Roosevelt tram. The pizza was fantastic! The guys at the front were kind and recommended some good options, and they even gave us a free slice! Definitely stop here!

Response from the owner

Elena, your wonderful review truly makes our day! We're thrilled to hear that you and your friend enjoyed your visit after the tram ride. Our team loves sharing their favorite pizza options, and it's fantastic that you got to enjoy a complimentary slice! Thank you for recommending us, and we can’t wait to welcome you back for more delicious pizza soon! 🍕❤️

Dalton VegaLocal guide
3 months ago

Classic NYC style pizza. This place knocked it out of the park and the staff were friendly and polite. Highly recommend for a quick bite of high quality pizza with very little wait 🍕

KarenLocal guide
4 months ago

Ratings are real 10/10. Super crunchy and fresh pizza. Highly recommend, can’t wait to come back for more slices.

AlexandraLocal guide
4 months ago

We ordered the large cheese pizza and garlic knots. Wow! Both were delicious. The delivery was so fast that we got to eat our food when it was still hot and tasting freshly removed from the oven. Kids love that there aren’t any green things on this pizza.

Ruben PliegoLocal guide
4 months ago

I was blown away! Crispy well done pizza. Right off 2nd Ave and 57th st.

LuceteLocal guide
8 months ago

Wanted a quick dinner and got a slice of margarita pizza for $5.95. Service was great. Pizza slice was reheated which made the dough crispy and good.

Reviews sourced from Google. Displayed for informational purposes. Ratings reflect reviewer opinions at the time of posting.

Been here? Share one sentence.

No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.

0/280

Anonymous · Reviewed before publishing

Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?

Explore

LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave) is one of many healthy restaurants in our directory. See Midtown East restaurants by health grade, healthy spots across Manhattan, and NYC restaurant health inspection grades.

LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave) is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Manhattan, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.