Connolly's

What a fun experience. We haven't found this place by accident and figuring give it a try and it was amazing. The appetizers the shepherd's pie and chicken were perfectly cooked and very hearty. Definitely worth going back again.

A darling Irish tavern in the heart of the theater district. Lunch was outside in the comfortable rooftop dining area which was inviting, airy and spacious. We had a crisp salad with jumbo shrimp and a nicely done chicken sandwich platter. The waitstaff was friendly, professional and attentive to every need, including providing ice for an earlier foot mishap. Connolly's made our NYC visit all the more enjoyable!

Fantastic bar , food was amazing, great service and the staff really welcoming.. brilliant range of beers even sell a classic from the 80s /90s which you can't get in the UK anymore

I don’t remember much from my experience but I can say it was a very amazing one. The welcoming atmosphere and staff paired with phenomenal and quick service made for a first time visit that I will never forget. Very memorable and fun time, I will be visiting again when I return to NYC.

The food was decent. Calamari is a skip. Chicken Pot Pie was worth it! We enjoyed what we got and it was a good place to warm up and get to decompress from traveling. Service felt like we were rushed. The location to our hotel could not be beat.

Recently traveled over from Co . Mayo to Celebrate my Daughters 21st Birthday ,I was Looking for a Spot for Dinner for around 15 people , Connolly’s was ideal, Great food and Service, Prices are very good for the middle of Manhattan. Staff are Lovely. We had a Super night, And a big thank you to Connolly’s Manger Orla who great, Nothing was any trouble. See you guys on our next visit. Kind Regards Sean

Our favourite bar during our entire stay. We visited every day after our first visit was so great, and it became our local! The food was delicious and the service impeccable. Special shout out to Darren the legend. He made us feel so welcome every visit, especially with how busy this bar is and he remembered us and our drinks order and even the football team my parter supported so the bar felt very homely. Would 10/10 recommend. Get yourselves to Connolly’s guys. Will be back next year

After finding a pizza place that we wanted to go to closed we decided to check out Connolly's. Upon entering we were told to go upstairs for quicker service, so we did and we're immediately seated. A server grabbed us waters and I eventually ordered a downeast cider from MA. The cider was super refreshing and had hints of sweetness without being too overpowering.<br><br>With my stomach not being too happy I ordered a baked potato and my mom the fish and chips substituting the fries for onion rings. Well the onion rings, to put it as nice as possible, had seen better days. They were way over cooked and hard as bricks--we did not need to even bite into one to notice this! Thankfully the server understood and swapped out the rings for another piece of fish.<br><br>And speaking of the fish it was amazing! Lightly fried and a little crispy around the edges it made every bite so good--no tartar sauce needed! Also, the meal came with coleslaw, which was nice surprise. It was cool and creamy and delicious as well. One of the servers recommended that next time we should get vinegar with the fish as it makes it even better.<br><br>Great service and good food.

Make sure you have a reservation! We did and were able to get seated faster ... but 30 minutes later than the reservation time. It was a Saturday night in early December and therefore busy. The crowds from Rockefeller Center Spilled Out for blocks in all directions. So getting to the restaurant was a challenge. The food was just okay. It came out very fast, the staff was very attentive and friendly. They're all doing the best they can. A very busy restaurant this Saturday night. They have to say it again, make sure you have a reservation! Pictures is Lance stew and fish and chips. Also other entrees are bangers and mash, potato leek soup, and then pump food.

This was an absolutely wonderful dining experience. The booth seating was awesome. A nice and quiet atmosphere. This is the best Fish & Chips I’ve had in NYC. I’ve tried several places but Connolly’s got it right. I did make a reservation but it’s not needed. I recommend Connolly’s highly and cannot wait to return.

Is Irish pub and restaurant is a fine choice for dinner before or after your show just off Broadway. We had the bangers and mash and the lamb burger both of which were delicious. Their Guinness is poured right from a tap and their establishment is clean and well-staffed.

I love the booth seating at this location. Norma the host was so nice and hospitable. She really makes you feel like you're at home. The Guiness steak was absolutely delicious and the Irish Cream Cheesecake is to die for.

Exceeded my expectations. 👏👏👏 This s a gem. The beers on tap are stellar. The beer lines are calibrated and cleaned and ON POINT. I ordered the Bangers and Mash with a side of curry fries. Everyone, this is Legit* (see attached photos). Also, this pub and its staff prides themselves on being the very best. Indeed. As an expert on service of excellents, this ...this will meet your expectations and beyond. Kudos Connolly, you would be proud 👏

Sasha and Ronan really made our evening a spectacular one. The service was great, the ambiance was casual and homey. The dim lighting maybe hiding a lot more than it seems, as the whole place needs a bit of a cleaning, and there was a funky smell as you sat at the bar.<br><br>The food was not bad, I enjoyed the Shepherd's Pie the best.<br><br>The Bangers were over cooked, fried to an almost burnt and dried out texture, and the mashed potatoes served with it, were under seasoned, however, I enjoyed the sauce & onions.<br><br>The Fish & Chips were not the best I've had, the batter itself was heavy, and it was a bit burnt as well.<br><br>I figure the kitchen was trying to close, and they wanted to kick the orders out quickly, thus some of our dishes were burnt.<br><br>Drinks were good here!

Overall, solid experience but nothing to call home for. Standard pub with the conventional selections, exactly what you’d expect.<br><br>Went on a Saturday after 5pm and was seated promptly for four people. Most of the tables were packed by that point so we lucked out.<br><br>Food: Not a huge menu but they have what you’d expect: fish and chips, sheppard’s pie, chicken pot pie, burgers, corn beef, etc. We got nachos to start, and mains: the Reuben sandwich, fish and chips, and turkey burger. All were fine- not the best and not the worst. Prices were a bit high for the quality, but you’d expect as much in Times Square area.<br><br>Drinks: The noticeable difference is that they have over 40 beers on tap. We got the Connolly’s Red Ales and they were pretty good.<br><br>Service: Pretty good for a packed house. Prompt to sit, drinks came within reasonable time, food came fairly short after too.<br><br>Atmosphere: Exactly what you’d expect for an Irish pub. They have funky door handles so that was an interesting difference.