Pizza restaurant

Capizzi

Hell's KitchenManhattan

4.6· 2,360 reviewsClosed now
Capizzi — pizza restaurant — in Hell's Kitchen — Manhattan — NYC
Capizzi interior — Hell's Kitchen

Hell's Kitchen

Manhattan

The brief

About Capizzi

Small, family-owned brick-oven pizzeria serving Neapolitan-style pies in an old-fashioned space.

Health inspection

NYC DOHMH Grade A

A

Score9(lower is better)

Inspected12/2/2024

Grade A is the highest mark from NYC's Department of Health — about 90% of restaurants earn it.

How grades work

Community Rating

4.6

½

out of 5

2,360 community reviews

Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.

Community-sourced rating

Reviews

What diners say about Capizzi

15 verified Google reviews

4.8

15 reviews

5
13
4
1
3
1
2
0
1
0
black_bourbon87Local guide
2 weeks ago

I'm Italian, so I'm quite picky about pizza. I must say this one was ok-ish, not bad and not great. I would not come back, but I'd say it's ok if you don't have high STANDARDS. Service was kind and quick.

Edgar HernandezLocal guide
2 weeks ago

Small pizza place that has delicious pizza. We enjoyed it. The tiny cokes are the best.

Yuri Paik (Yuri)Local guide
4 weeks ago

At first wasn’t sure because we were hurriedly seated at a table that hadn’t been cleaned. But then the service was very lovely and accommodating. The pizza here is really good, some of the best tomato sauce I’ve had in general. Would love to come back to try their other menu items!

Meghan BakerLocal guide
a month ago

This was a cute little pizza place. Wood fired pizzas and bottled sodas. The restaurant must’ve been setting up for an event or something because they started removing all the tables and chairs around us while we ate. So it was hard to get our waiters attention for refills etc. Other than that, the pizza was delicious, and the Nutella pizza dessert was incredible.

Justin PLocal guide
a month ago

Very high quality pizzeria delivering fresh ingredients. Brought the family here when visiting and everyone loved it. Get a cannoli and slice of tiramisu for desert, you’ll be glad you didn’t skip desert.

Matt CalleLocal guide
2 months ago

What a great way to end the night. we just wanted a quick place to eat before heading back into new jersey and found this place after the auto show. Prices were great! food as well, but the Nutella Pizza stole the show! my girlfriend doesn’t like dessert but even she loved it and glad we brought some home. it’s perfectly right next to Port Authority as well! catch a bus just like that. very cozy, which provides an atmosphere to relax

Paola DavisLocal guide
2 months ago

I'm Italian and I have to say that not only the atmosphere is wonderful as all the staff is but the food really surprised me, whenever I had pizza in the US it was the typical American pizza but here it's Italian 100%, the dough was light and delicious, the tomatoe sauce was san marzano and they didn't rushed us out but we felt like we were in Italy.<br>Mozzarella di bufala was authentic.<br>The staff was so friendly and the old Italian pieces of furniture's of the owner added to the wonderful atmosphere.<br>The prices were very reasonable.<br>Definitely recommend Capizzi😍😍😍

Ann ShermanLocal guide
5 months ago

This is the perfect place to go in New York City if you’re looking for a quaint, charming family owned pizza place. Best pizza we have had in NYC! Wonderful wine & beer selection as well! The atmosphere is inviting and cozy and the service is excellent. We had the pleasure to meet Will who took great care of us! Everything about this place is 5+ stars you would be remiss if you didn’t stop here! Thank you!

Amabile Brunhara AngareLocal guide
5 months ago

Will and Alison were the best servers, they took care of our table and were extremely helpful, efficient and friendly.<br>The food was AMAZING. I must say that I’m pretty hard to impress when it comes to pizza but this place was not only amazing with their savory pizza but also with their Nutella pizza (a must try).<br>Ambience was great and my family and I had the best time.

Bella H
6 months ago

Fantastic quaint pizza place not far from port authority & Times Square. Great gluten free crust, incredible wine, and the caprese was delicious. Service was quick and kind. Overall an incredible dining experience

Jinhee ParkLocal guide
8 months ago

Marinara on the pizza was fresh, tasted very clean and like real food, no weird chemical artificial tastes. Dough complemented the toppings well. Spinach arancini was ok- there was nothing wrong with it, just personally didn’t prefer the mildness of it so I should’ve just chosen a different menu.<br>Waitress was attentive and quick to know what you needed without you trying to make eye contact for ages.

Kymble JohnsonLocal guide
9 months ago

I was visiting New York and one of the few foods on my bucket list was good, Neapolitan pizza. This place did not disappoint! My favorite was the hot honey pepperoni - the roni was freshly sliced and thick. I also really enjoyed the prosciutto and arugula. Aside from the food, the service was great, and the vibe was perfect: polished, calm, warm, and comfy. I would definitely recommend to anyone wanting authentic Neopolitan pizza in the Hell’s Kitchen area.

Luke AdamsLocal guide
11 months ago

Fun place we found randomly one night and luckily they had an open table. Place has less than 10 tables. Service was friendly and efficient and we enjoyed our pizzas. We ordered the burrata appetizer and it was very good, but it was similar to our pizzas, so we probably wouldnt order again.

Mayu MLocal guide
11 months ago

Had lunch here before a Broadway show and it was a great choice! The place feels like a little escape to Italy. Calm, cozy, and friendly staff. The pizza was light and flavorful, with toppings like mushrooms and onions that made each bite different. Very delicious! We ended up staying for dessert too. Tiramisu was perfectly sweet and bitter. Loved it! We will definitely be back to this hidden gem.

Shivendra RaiLocal guide
Edited a year ago

One of the best pizzas I have had in the states. It looks so vibrant and fresh plus you have the best manager and staff. They have the old fashioned way of making the pizza which looks fascinating and tastes amazing.<br>No post eating complaint and it hits your stomach well. There were vegetarian options and they can customise some of the items.<br>Loved the ambiance and the service. We had a Margherita and one of their classics with peppers, mushrooms & onions.<br>You pay for the experience so no complaints

Reviews sourced from Google. Displayed for informational purposes. Ratings reflect reviewer opinions at the time of posting.

Been here? Share one sentence.

No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.

0/280

Anonymous · Reviewed before publishing

Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?

Explore

Capizzi is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Manhattan, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.