Cafe

American Girl Place New York

Midtown EastManhattan

4.5· 4,890 reviewsClosed now
American Girl Place New York — cafe — in Midtown East — Manhattan — NYC
American Girl Place New York interior — Midtown East

Midtown East

Manhattan

The brief

About American Girl Place New York

Upscale shop for specialty dolls & accessories (some with doll hair salons & cafes).

Community Rating

4.5

½

out of 5

4,890 community reviews

Rating aggregated from community reviews across platforms. Read full reviews on Google or Yelp for detailed diner experiences.

Community-sourced rating

Reviews

What diners say about American Girl Place New York

15 verified Google reviews · 15 with owner responses

4.3

15 reviews

5
11
4
1
3
0
2
2
1
1
jolene howardLocal guide
3 weeks ago

Booked an afternoon mid-week birthday party here for a young adult and it might be the best decision I made this year! We had a private room (it was pink! with a chandelier!, the AG party host played great music, we were offered crafts, cute upgrades and party attendees who didn’t bring dolls were offered AG companions of their choosing for the fete. Adorable! Lunch included fanciful non-alcoholic drinks and standard American options (like sliders). We were offered cinnamon rolls upon arrival and tiered snack trays before the meal. The cake was pretty and yummy! We left with gift bags and at least one guest said she loved it so much that she plans on having her own birthday party here next year.

Response from the owner

How wonderful, Jolene to hear of such a great celebration. American Girl is proud of our associates bringing special adventures to our visitors. Happy Birthday, belated but heartfelt. Thank you for the5-star rating & sharing your day with us.

ibin raheem
3 weeks ago

Cool experience for my daughter, cafe was decent. I really didn’t appreciate the lady helping us. She constantly was trying to take my black daughter to the white dolls, and even said “ these dolls hair is easier to work with”. Well we had a nice discussion, on appreciating the beauty in your own skin and hair, and we helped ourselves from then on.

Response from the owner

We apologize that your experience wasn't the premier service you expected. American Girl strives to provide exceptional experiences in our stores, bistros and cafés. Would you kindly email your contact info to reviewsites@americangirl.com and put Google/NYC in the subject field? We'd love an opportunity to turn this around.

Elaine Rios
a month ago

We went to celebrate my granddaughters 9th birthday. We took her best friend and the girls absolutely loved the store. They picked a few things and then we went for a late lunch . We were seated promptly. The lunch was delicious and very reasonably priced. Our server Ramon was outstanding and went above and beyond to make our girls day special. It happened to be Mothers Day and I couldn’t think of a better way to spend it. If you have a young girl do not miss this experience.

Response from the owner

Thank you for celebrating your Granddaughter's 9th Birthday with us at American Girl New York Elaine! We appreciate your outstanding rating and review and will be happy to share your compliments to our amazing team member. We strive to provide memorable experiences with our guests and are thrilled that we could provide special days for both your Birthday girl and her Grandmother on Mothers day. Please come back and see us again soon.🎂💐🎂💐🎂<br>

Marci BussLocal guide
Edited a month ago

I took my 8 yr old granddaughter for her first visit. We had an appt with the salon for her and her doll. I watched the stylists with other girls chatting and being kind. Not so much ours. In fact she criticized my granddaughter’s hair for being cut (ethnic curly hair)<br>She then completely straightened her hair without even asking if okay with me.<br>The mirror above the salon states “ Be your own kind of beautiful “. To me, that’s encouraging girls to feel beautiful as they are. Not with criticism or changing their hair type all together. The girl that checked us in (Emily) was super kind and gave us suggestions for her curly hair. Then, the stylist did what she wanted. Another employee (Paige) even stood over her and made simply awful faces watching her getting her hair done This made my granddaughter uncomfortable and she even began to cry.<br><br>This was our vacation and our vacation money. I never expected to spend it to feel judged and that her hair needed to be changed. We embrace her natural curls and encourage her to feel beautiful exactly as she is!<br><br>Update: Asked to send email (which I did same day). No response from American Girl at all

Response from the owner

We apologize that your experience wasn't the premier service you expected. American Girl strives to provide exceptional experiences in our stores, bistros and cafés. Would you kindly email your contact info to reviewsites@americangirl.com and put Google/NYC in the subject field? We'd love an opportunity to turn this around.

Jade JohnsLocal guide
2 months ago

I brought my 7 year old daughter for her birthday to do the Spring Flower Painting and brunch. 10/10 was made to feel so comfortable and I give credit to every worker from the front desk down to the servers. Absolutely awesome time celebrating my girl!!<br>AND THE CAFE FOOD WAS DELICIOUS!!!!<br><br>Edit- I brought my two other daughters and they were provided dolls to borrow during the meal and painting. I love how they include everyone!!

Response from the owner

Thank you for joining us for the Spring Flower Painting and Brunch Jade! In addition we were honored to be able to celebrate your Birthday Girl with you and her sisters too! Your rating and review is absolutely awesome-we appreciate your kind words and will share your feedback with our incredible staff. Our Dolls had a great time sharing sometime with new friends too. We look forward to welcoming you all back again soon. 🎉💐👩‍🎨💐👩‍🎨💐👩‍🎨🎉

Lauren ChristieLocal guide
3 months ago

I sent my truly me doll Megan to the doll hospital about 4 weeks ago. She came back with new hair and her eyes were reset. She looks so amazing. I love her as always loved her for over 20 years. Thank you so much for making this happen.

Response from the owner

Thank you for caring for and loving your American Girl doll Lauren! It is very rewarding to receive your amazing rating and review for our Doll Care Center services. We appreciate being able to offer quality care and premier services for our fans and their cherished dolls. Megan was a pleasure to meet and we know that she was excited to get back to you. Enjoy! 🩷

SLocal guide
3 months ago

We visited American Girl Place New York for the first time and absolutely loved it! The doll displays are so fun, nostalgic, and unique. There are cute photo opportunities, and the salon is such a fun addition to an already amazing store. There is such an amazing selection of dolls and doll accessories. American Girl Place New York is fun for all ages to shop at. American Girl Place New York is a must see while in New York City! Highly recommend!

Response from the owner

Thank you for the shining review & 5 stars! American Girl strives to provide experiences and imagination to entice child's play. Please visit again very soon.

Nath CeeLocal guide
3 months ago

We had an amazing hair salon experience. We were luck to end up with a phenomenal hair stylist, Amanda. She was gentle with my daughter's natural curly hair. My daughter absolutely loved her hair style as well as her doll's. We look forward to doing this experience again ! The store is so cute and there are so many shopping options. Hot wheels for the boys and books for the older girls who may not be as in to the dolls anymore. Both of my daughters left happy.

Response from the owner

Thank you for your kind words, Nathalie! We're delighted to hear that your experience in the salon was magical, and that both of your daughters enjoyed our store. We hope to see you all again soon! ♥♥♥

Nafisa QobilzodaLocal guide
6 months ago

I visited the American Girl Store in Manhattan with my daughter, and we really enjoyed it. The store is beautiful, spacious, and full of interactive areas. My daughter had a great time and was truly delighted. The variety of dolls is impressive and everything is bright and engaging.<br><br>One small suggestion — not a complaint. As a Muslim mom, I would love to see dolls wearing a hijab included in the collection. It would be wonderful to show such dolls to my daughter and buy one for her, and I believe many Muslim mothers would feel the same. It would make the store even more inclusive and welcoming.<br><br>Overall, the store is wonderful, and we will definitely come back again.

Response from the owner

Thank you Nafisa for your comments and the 5-star rating. We appreciate your suggestion & will pass it onto our leadership team. American Girl would love to see you & your family again soon.

Ricki GibsonLocal guide
7 months ago

I love it here. I didn’t have my daughter with me this trip so it wasn’t as much fun as it would have been with her. There is the salon, tearoom, and the shop. I just loved seeing all the dolls on display and there was even a basketball hoop to shoot baskets in.

Response from the owner

Thank you Ricki for your wonderful comments & 5-star rating. We would love to welcome you & your daughter for a grand adventure next time.

Dora CLocal guide
7 months ago

The American Girl store is truly magical. Everything is colorful, nostalgic, and full of heart, and the entire place is absolutely beautiful. The café is such a fun touch—the food is genuinely good, and it’s adorable how everything is themed for the dolls and kids. It’s such a sweet experience and really adds to the magic of the visit!<br>We did the lunch, hair, and nails salon package, and it was so much fun. We’ll definitely be coming back! I’m still so sad they closed the store in NC, but I’m grateful we can still enjoy the experience elsewhere.

Response from the owner

Dora, thank you for giving American Girl NYC a 5-star rating. We also miss our associates & customers in the NC area. Thankful we are that you & your family trekked to NYC to visit us. Please visit us as often as you are able.

Courtney HillLocal guide
8 months ago

OMG such a wonderful store. So many dolls and accessories. They do have a doll salon, but you have to make an appointment. The process were reasonable and they did have a sale section. I loved seeing all the beautiful dolls and their outfits.

Response from the owner

Thank you for sharing your wonderful rating and review for American Girl New York City Courtney! We are thrilled you enjoyed seeing all of our beautiful dolls, outfits, and accessories. Let us know if we can be of assistance in booking Reservations for your return visit, we are looking forward to it. 👩‍💼👩‍🚀👩‍🍳👩‍🌾👩‍🎨

MiaLocal guide
8 months ago

The American Girl store is literally magic. I have loved this brand since I was little & at 22 I still collect the dolls with the same excitement I had as a kid. Everything is colorful, nostalgic, and full of heart and the place is so beautiful. The café is also such a fun touch. The food is genuinely good, & it’s adorable how everything is themed for the dolls and kids. I totally get that it’s geared toward children, but since most kids come with their parents, I do think they could make the portion sizes a little bigger for adults. Still, it’s such a sweet experience and really adds to the magic of the visit!!

Response from the owner

Mia, your comments make our hearts at American Girl swell. Thank so kindly for sharing your experiences. We love that you have continued to be excited by American Girl dolls & experiences. Please visit us again soon.

Tahlia TsamaLocal guide
10 months ago

Another dream came true, getting to visit my dream American girl flagship store location. ✨What a fantastic and memorable mum and I both had walking through the 2 level displays, interactive games and photo opportunities in the store ! This was the location I had begged mum to take me to for a day trip as a child and dreamt of having my birthday here when I was younger. More tears were shed as I immersed myself in what I love most … my American girl dolls 💫🩷 Each store has unique displays and layouts which is really cool to see and compare to other stores that I plan to visit. What I loved most in the store was seeing each Girl of the year dolls displayed from 2001- 2024 and going through which ones I own . Also there was a beautiful display of all the historical dolls and seeing the retired dolls that are no longer sold on display for the first time was such a surreal experience 🫶🏼 I also had the opportunity to have the personal shopper experience during my visit which made the experience even more special . It still feels so surreal to be able to be up close to the dolls and their collections and chose what I’m wanting to buy instead of having to purchase through eBay or second hand🥺<br><br>I had my birthday at the American Girl cafe on Sunday - They say you can never be too old to have your dreams come true ✨🩷this birthday at the American girl cafe will be one I’ll never forget 🧁🎀💗🌷 This was the experience I had been dreaming to have ever since I was 11 years old and it truely feels so surreal that today was the day! The service was exceptional by all the staff at the American girl store / Cafe 🩷 It was such a special day to share my birthday here today! The food was absolutely delicious and there is so much to choice from. Having booked the deluxe party package we had a complementary choice of drink( I chose pink lemonade ), For starters we had Warm Welcome Cinnamon Buns and a tier loaded of food (Roasted beet hummus and Boursin mousse cucumber bite, carrot sticks, minch dipping sauce, cantaloupe and honeydew, strawberry-and'-grape fruit skewer, beef meatball, fried cheese rd marinara dipping sauce). For lunch we chose fancy bow tie pasta 🍝 and for desert we had the American girl signature cake with ice cream! This was the birthday I always had wanted as a child and it definitely met my expectations . What a magical birthday 🫶🏼🧁

Response from the owner

Thank you for sharing your Birthday with us at American Girl New York City Tahlia! What an honor to share in a dream visit and celebrate so many special moments with you. Receiving your exceptional rating and review along with continued interest and support is exactly what we strive to provide. Your fantastic feedback from your Personal Shopper reservation, shopping and Dining experience is sure to encourage guests to come in and see all of the magical opportunities that await from visiting any of our many locations. Happy Birthday wishes to last throughout the year-stop in anytime, we'll be here! 🎉🎈🍰🍨🧃

Amanda HolmesLocal guide
a year ago

We just left American girl and sadly our experience was very mixie. Initially, we did a phone order for pick up today. It was my six-year-old’s birthday. That went smooth and we worked with Emily one of the managers. Now for experience part… we let our daughter pick out a few more items in store we went to the café and they told us we couldn’t go in with un purchase items which wasn’t an issue. We said okay no problem we expressed we were pressed for time we had to leave by 3:15 our cafe reservation was for 2:15. Food was mediocre and cake was dry even the fruits were not fresh but for the price i guess that part was okay. Well upon us, leaving, they had taken our stuff and told us that café close at two, which makes no sense so now we had to frantically run around the store to find the items and to purchase which took us time. Then we have to speak to a manager and was told there’s managers for each department because we had another issue with the nail salon. My daughter got her nails done and sat for almost 20 minutes for them to dry and when we went to the café, and I touched her nails. They were still not dry and were smuggy in a nail tech so i know they painted her nails way too thick. I demanded a refund. Then the way my points were used i wasn’t even able to use them on the purchased items. So shout to saving money when we spent hundreds. To top it off we landed up 30 mins late and now cost us additional parking and me late for a work meeting and an appointment.

Response from the owner

Hello Amanda! We're so genuinely sorry to hear that your recent visit didn't meet your expectations, especially regarding the punctuality of appointments. Our aim is always to create amazing and memorable experiences in our café and salon for everyone who walks through our doors, and we deeply regret that you felt the overall experience didn't reflect our usual quality.<br><br>We'd love to learn more about your experience so we can understand where we fell short and how we can make things right. Would you be willing to share more details with us directly by emailing us at reviewsites@americangirl.com, including 'Google Review / NYC.' in the subject line? We truly value your input and hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back for a visit that meets your expectations!

Reviews sourced from Google. Displayed for informational purposes. Ratings reflect reviewer opinions at the time of posting.

Been here? Share one sentence.

No account needed. One honest sentence about your experience. All submissions are reviewed before publishing.

0/280

Anonymous · Reviewed before publishing

Was the health and dietary information on this page accurate?

Explore

American Girl Place New York is one of many healthy restaurants in our directory. See healthy restaurants in Midtown East, Manhattan's healthy dining scene, and NYC restaurant health inspection grades.

American Girl Place New York is listed in the Eat Real Food NYC directory — a curated database of healthy restaurants in Manhattan, verified with official NYC Department of Health inspection data.